{ "episode": 4, "title": "That's the Magic of Survivor", "air_date": "2026-10-14", "cutoff": "2026-10-16T17:42:26+00:00", "headline": "Jenna tries Toka one more time.", "question": "Why try to rebuild with Devin and Jelly after they have already voted against her?", "question_origin": "Original RPM adaptation of the Phase 1 evidence-derived question; named-author recap context, not a viewer-consensus claim.", "records": [ { "id": "IP01", "episode": 4, "base": "Informational", "players": [ "Kilby" ], "recipients": [ "Eric" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "WORKED", "title": "Kilby tells his Toka story. Eric offers backing.", "summary": "Eric says the account makes him want to support Kilby. Their shared interests and Eric’s prior wish for a buddy also matter.", "action": "Kilby frames himself as mistreated and seeks sympathy", "response": "Eric says the account makes him want revenge for Kilby and offers backing", "limit": "Eric offers backing; no ballot shows a flip. Kilby’s account alone does not prove how the old Toka group treated him.", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-012", "EVD-S51E04-014", "EVD-S51E04-027", "EVD-S51E04-028" ], "source_record_id": "IP01", "attribution": "DIRECTLY_ATTRIBUTED_CONTRIBUTION" }, { "id": "EX01", "episode": 4, "base": "Expert", "players": [ "Kristin" ], "recipients": [ "Toka food-guidance recipients; Mike explicitly credits benefit" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "WORKED", "title": "Kristin’s plant knowledge finds a practical audience.", "summary": "Toka gains a reported food source and Mike credits her help. This is practical acceptance, without a promise of vote protection.", "action": "Identifies usable food sources and offers practical guidance", "response": "Recipients rely on the guidance enough to report a new food source; Mike credits her knowledge with helping Toka", "limit": "The food advice counts once. It establishes practical acceptance, without vote protection or command of Toka.", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-016", "EVD-S51E04-017", "EVD-S51E04-029" ], "source_record_id": "EX01", "attribution": "SUPPORTED_CONTRIBUTION" }, { "id": "IP02", "episode": 4, "base": "Informational", "players": [ "Kristin" ], "recipients": [ "Carter" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "FAILED", "title": "Carter does not buy Kristin’s repair attempt.", "summary": "Her explanation about the earlier vote meets explicit distrust. A failed attempt is still part of the episode’s record.", "action": "Explains the old vote and seeks Carter’s return to the fold", "response": "Carter interprets the explanation as tactical and explicitly says he no longer trusts her", "limit": "Carter resists this explanation. That does not tell us whether Kristin can regain his trust later.", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-018" ], "source_record_id": "IP02", "attribution": "DIRECTLY_ATTRIBUTED_CONTRIBUTION" }, { "id": "IP03", "episode": 4, "base": "Informational", "players": [ "Alexis" ], "recipients": [ "Jenna" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "BACKFIRED", "title": "Alexis’s warning travels back to her opponents.", "summary": "Jenna doubts the pitch and tells Devin and Jelly what Alexis is saying. Alexis stays, but the warning does not recruit Jenna.", "action": "Urges Jenna to break from them; makes the warning repeatedly", "response": "Jenna doubts her purpose, continues her old-Toka plan and relays the warning to the people Alexis names", "limit": "The warning backfires with Jenna even though it describes real danger. The repeated appeals and the shoes request belong to this one sequence.", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-019", "EVD-S51E04-020", "EVD-S51E04-034", "EVD-S51E04-035", "EVD-S51E04-037" ], "source_record_id": "IP03", "attribution": "STRONGLY_SUPPORTED_CONTRIBUTION" }, { "id": "IP04", "episode": 4, "base": "Informational", "players": [ "Jenna" ], "recipients": [ "Jelly", "Devin" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "MIXED", "title": "Jenna gets a reaction, but not the result she wants.", "summary": "Jelly and Devin react against Alexis’s arguments. Other loyalties and old distrust still stand between Jenna and a dependable vote.", "action": "Relays Alexis’s arguments to support rebuilding with Devin/Jelly", "response": "Devin describes Alexis as disruptive; Jelly responds negatively and considers an Alexis target, while retaining concerns about Ori", "limit": "Jenna’s relay is a separate action from Alexis’s warning. The record counts each once and does not make either the sole cause of the vote.", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-020", "EVD-S51E04-034", "EVD-S51E04-037", "EVD-S51E04-038", "EVD-S51E04-039" ], "source_record_id": "IP04", "attribution": "STRONGLY_SUPPORTED_CONTRIBUTION" }, { "id": "REF01", "episode": 4, "base": "Referent", "players": [ "Mike" ], "recipients": [ "Thien An", "Maggie" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "BACKFIRED", "title": "Mike’s new warmth meets suspicion.", "summary": "Thien An and Maggie question his broad offers after Patt leaves. The backfire is their wary response, not proof everyone rejects him.", "action": "Presents recipients as people he would be close to outside the game while offering himself widely", "response": "Thien An/Maggie treat the timing and breadth as opportunistic; expressed wariness is reinforced rather than a dependable commitment secured", "limit": "The backfire is Thien An and Maggie’s wary response. It does not establish universal rejection, a changed ballot or entirely new distrust.", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-023", "EVD-S51E04-024" ], "source_record_id": "REF01", "attribution": "SUPPORTED_CONTRIBUTION" }, { "id": "REF02", "episode": 4, "base": "Referent", "players": [ "Devin", "Jelly", "Alexis" ], "recipients": [ "Ori" ], "shared": true, "effectiveness": "WORKED", "title": "Ori names the ties behind his target.", "summary": "His connections with Devin and Jelly, plus his bond with Alexis, shape his stated choice of Jenna. One response has shared credit.", "action": "Those overlapping ties are invoked in Ori’s account of his Jenna target choice", "response": "Ori explicitly says Jenna’s position with Devin/Jelly and his relationship with Alexis align him against Jenna, and backs that target", "limit": "One response has shared credit. It does not prove coordinated control by Devin, Jelly and Alexis, or make romance the cause of Ori’s choice.", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-026", "EVD-S51E04-036" ], "source_record_id": "REF02", "attribution": "DIRECTLY_ATTRIBUTED_CONTRIBUTION" } ], "players": [ { "player": "Aaliyah", "slug": "aaliyah", "full_name": "Aaliyah Puglia", "profile": "24 · Providence, Rhode Island · Chef", "portrait": "/images/players/survivor-51/official/aaliyah.jpg", "tribe": "Toka", "previous_tribe": "Toka", "moved": false, "active": false, "eligible": false, "status": "Earlier exit", "headline": "Her season record ends at her exit.", "summary": "Aaliyah left in Episode 1. Her original findings remain available without adding a new Episode 4 assessment.", "action": "No new action or response is assigned to her here.", "result": "The chart keeps her earlier checkpoint and leaves subsequent episodes blank.", "next_test": "Her game has ended; blank later checkpoints do not mean zero strength.", "limit": "Her earlier Shot in the Dark and other recorded events are not counted again.", "history": [ { "episode": 1, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 1, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": { "FAILED": 1, "WORKED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "PE-S51E01-016-LEG", "PE-S51E01-018-REF" ] }, { "episode": 2, "status": "PRIOR_EXIT", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 3, "status": "PRIOR_EXIT", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 4, "status": "PRIOR_EXIT", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] } ], "record_ids": [], "evidence_ids": [] }, { "player": "Alexis", "slug": "alexis", "full_name": "Alexis Levine", "profile": "34 · Atlanta, Georgia · Criminal defense attorney", "portrait": "/images/players/survivor-51/official/alexis.jpg", "tribe": "Savu", "previous_tribe": "Savu", "moved": false, "active": true, "eligible": true, "status": "Still playing", "headline": "Her warning comes back around.", "summary": "Alexis sees the crack between Jenna, Devin and Jelly. She tries to widen it; Jenna carries the warning straight back to them.", "action": "She urges Jenna to vote against Devin or Jelly and asks for shoes as collateral. Jenna refuses.", "result": "The warning fails to recruit Jenna and makes Alexis a topic of suspicion. Alexis stays, with Ori explicitly valuing their bond.", "next_test": "Keeping Ori’s support and recruiting a new partner are different tasks. This round establishes the support, not a lasting majority.", "limit": "Alexis’s survival does not make the warning a successful pitch. Her warning also describes a real risk to Jenna.", "history": [ { "episode": 1, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 2, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 1, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": { "WORKED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "PE-S51E02-A02-INF" ] }, { "episode": 3, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 4, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 1, "shared_worked": 1, "outcomes": { "BACKFIRED": 1, "WORKED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "IP03", "REF02" ] } ], "record_ids": [ "IP03", "REF02" ], "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-005", "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-019", "EVD-S51E04-035", "EVD-S51E04-040", "EVD-S51E04-042", "EVD-S51E04-043" ] }, { "player": "Ana", "slug": "ana", "full_name": "Ana Sani", "profile": "34 · Toronto, Ontario · Voice actress", "portrait": "/images/players/survivor-51/official/ana.jpg", "tribe": "Savu", "previous_tribe": "Savu", "moved": false, "active": false, "eligible": false, "status": "Earlier exit", "headline": "Her earlier episode stays intact.", "summary": "Ana left before Episode 4. Her earlier findings remain in the season record.", "action": "No new Episode 4 action or response is assigned to her.", "result": "Her last tribe and earlier exit remain visible.", "next_test": "Her game has ended; the original Episode 2 and later-source boundaries remain separate.", "limit": "The earlier tally conflict is not repaired by later episodes or by a missing point in her chart.", "history": [ { "episode": 1, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 2, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 0, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": { "BACKFIRED": 1, "MIXED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "PE-S51E02-A01-INF", "PE-S51E02-A05-INF" ] }, { "episode": 3, "status": "PRIOR_EXIT", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 4, "status": "PRIOR_EXIT", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] } ], "record_ids": [], "evidence_ids": [] }, { "player": "Brady", "slug": "brady", "full_name": "Brady Booker", "profile": "27 · Knoxville, Tennessee · Professional wrestler", "portrait": "/images/players/survivor-51/official/brady.jpg", "tribe": "Toka", "previous_tribe": "Toka", "moved": false, "active": true, "eligible": true, "status": "Still playing", "headline": "He says it is time to lower the volume.", "summary": "Brady describes feeling humbled after the Patt vote and says he wants to reduce his intensity.", "action": "He talks about surviving a fractured Toka and then competes with the new tribe.", "result": "Toka is safe. The record does not identify a new person changing a game decision because of Brady’s adjustment.", "next_test": "His change of approach would need a later response before it becomes another Power finding.", "limit": "His own account supports the feeling. Neither an expression nor survival alone supplies a strength judgment.", "history": [ { "episode": 1, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 0, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": { "MIXED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "PE-S51E01-012-INF" ] }, { "episode": 2, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 3, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 0, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": { "INDETERMINATE": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "RP01" ] }, { "episode": 4, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] } ], "record_ids": [], "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-002", "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-022" ] }, { "player": "Carter", "slug": "carter", "full_name": "Carter Krull", "profile": "24 · Sioux Falls, South Dakota · Livestock farmer", "portrait": "/images/players/survivor-51/official/carter.jpg", "tribe": "Toka", "previous_tribe": "Toka", "moved": false, "active": true, "eligible": true, "status": "Still playing", "headline": "Useful advice does not erase an old vote.", "summary": "Kristin tries to bring Carter back into cooperation. He says he sees the appeal as tactical and still does not trust her.", "action": "He resists that repair and separately exchanges trust and target preferences with Thien An.", "result": "The repair fails at his stated trust response. His new assurances with Thien An remain untested at Tribal.", "next_test": "He and Thien An discuss different target preferences; their friendship does not make every decision identical.", "limit": "His carried idol remains separate from any demonstrated use. No exact new use or expiry is invented.", "history": [ { "episode": 1, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 2, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 3, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 1, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": { "FAILED": 1, "WORKED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "IP06", "REF01" ] }, { "episode": 4, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] } ], "record_ids": [], "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-002", "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-018", "EVD-S51E04-025" ] }, { "player": "Cristian", "slug": "cristian", "full_name": "Cristian Chavez", "profile": "26 · Salt Lake City, Utah · Head of HR", "portrait": "/images/players/survivor-51/official/cristian.jpg", "tribe": "Dina", "previous_tribe": "Savu", "moved": true, "active": true, "eligible": true, "status": "Still playing", "headline": "Four old Savus give him a starting plan.", "summary": "Cristian sees a numerical majority on the new Dina tribe and describes possible future targets.", "action": "He lays out that starting position and works the maze with Linnea.", "result": "Dina wins immunity. Four old affiliations do not establish command of four ballots.", "next_test": "A future choice would have to show whether the old group acts together.", "limit": "His stated confidence and challenge performance are not a Power score or another proved social use.", "history": [ { "episode": 1, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 2, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 3, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 4, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] } ], "record_ids": [], "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-011", "EVD-S51E04-031", "EVD-S51E04-032" ] }, { "player": "Devin", "slug": "devin", "full_name": "Devin Way", "profile": "33 · Los Angeles, California · Actor", "portrait": "/images/players/survivor-51/official/devin.jpg", "tribe": "Savu", "previous_tribe": "Toka", "moved": true, "active": true, "eligible": true, "status": "Still playing", "headline": "He has choices—and unfinished business.", "summary": "Devin hears Jenna’s offer to stay Toka strong, but their old conflict still matters to him. Ori already wants to keep their cross-tribe connection.", "action": "He considers Jenna and Alexis as targets and reacts to Jenna’s account of Alexis’s warnings.", "result": "Ori links his Jenna target to his ties with Devin and Jelly, alongside his bond with Alexis. That is one shared finding.", "next_test": "A connection with Ori gives him another route. It does not establish control of every vote or settle how long that route lasts.", "limit": "The shared finding appears on Devin, Jelly and Alexis’s cards. It counts once in the episode total. Extra-vote use is not confirmed.", "history": [ { "episode": 1, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 1, "shared_worked": 1, "outcomes": { "MIXED": 1, "FAILED": 1, "WORKED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "PE-S51E01-005-INF", "PE-S51E01-013-INF", "PE-S51E01-019-REF" ] }, { "episode": 2, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 3, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 1, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": { "WORKED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "IP03" ] }, { "episode": 4, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 1, "shared_worked": 1, "outcomes": { "WORKED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "REF02" ] } ], "record_ids": [ "REF02" ], "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-004", "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-020", "EVD-S51E04-021", "EVD-S51E04-026", "EVD-S51E04-033", "EVD-S51E04-036", "EVD-S51E04-039", "EVD-S51E04-043" ] }, { "player": "Eric", "slug": "eric", "full_name": "Eric Macksoud", "profile": "34 · Windsor Locks, Connecticut · Mental health counselor", "portrait": "/images/players/survivor-51/official/eric.jpg", "tribe": "Dina", "previous_tribe": "Savu", "moved": true, "active": true, "eligible": true, "status": "Still playing", "headline": "A new buddy, an old promise.", "summary": "Eric is delighted to connect with Kilby. The closer they look, the more Sharonda worries about keeping the old Savu four together.", "action": "He offers Kilby backing and then reassures Sharonda that their relationship still holds.", "result": "His response gives Kilby a bounded Informational finding. It does not establish that Eric abandons the four or changes a ballot.", "next_test": "The next choice would need to test those overlapping promises. He sits out the challenge and Dina is safe.", "limit": "Receiving a pitch is different from making a counted use. No individual worked-use finding is assigned to Eric in Episode 4.", "history": [ { "episode": 1, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 2, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 3, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 4, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] } ], "record_ids": [], "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-014", "EVD-S51E04-027", "EVD-S51E04-028", "EVD-S51E04-030" ] }, { "player": "Jelly", "slug": "jelly", "full_name": "Angelica “Jelly” Loblack", "profile": "29 · Bloomington, Indiana · Sociology professor", "portrait": "/images/players/survivor-51/official/jelly.jpg", "tribe": "Savu", "previous_tribe": "Toka", "moved": true, "active": true, "eligible": true, "status": "Still playing", "headline": "Alexis annoys her. Losing Ori worries her.", "summary": "Jenna’s account makes Alexis look dangerous to Jelly. But voting Alexis out could also hurt the helicopter alliance Jelly wants to keep.", "action": "She weighs the two targets, acknowledges her connection with Ori and describes holding an idol.", "result": "Ori explicitly backs a Jenna target because of his relationships. Jelly’s concern about a rift helps explain her tradeoff; it is not a second proved change of mind.", "next_test": "Her frustration with Devin’s matchmaking does not establish a breakup with him. The next decision still needs its own evidence.", "limit": "No idol play is confirmed. Ori’s stated choice is one shared Referent finding, not a map of everyone’s ballot.", "history": [ { "episode": 1, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 1, "shared_worked": 1, "outcomes": { "WORKED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "PE-S51E01-019-REF" ] }, { "episode": 2, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 1, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": { "WORKED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "PE-S51E02-A04-INF" ] }, { "episode": 3, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 4, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 1, "shared_worked": 1, "outcomes": { "WORKED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "REF02" ] } ], "record_ids": [ "REF02" ], "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-004", "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-020", "EVD-S51E04-026", "EVD-S51E04-034", "EVD-S51E04-037", "EVD-S51E04-038", "EVD-S51E04-041", "EVD-S51E04-042" ] }, { "player": "Jenna", "slug": "jenna", "full_name": "Jenna Doore", "profile": "30 · Toledo, Ohio · Wedding photographer", "portrait": "/images/players/survivor-51/official/jenna.jpg", "tribe": "Savu", "previous_tribe": "Toka", "moved": true, "active": false, "eligible": true, "status": "Voted out · Episode 4", "headline": "She gives Toka another chance.", "summary": "Jenna tries to turn three old Tokas into three votes. Telling Devin and Jelly about Alexis’s warning gets their attention, but it doesn’t secure her place.", "action": "She pitches keeping the three together, names Alexis as her target and refuses to give Alexis her shoes as a guarantee.", "result": "Jelly and Devin react against Alexis’s pitch. Ori still wants Jenna out, and Jenna leaves.", "next_test": "Her game ends here. Her later account explains what she thought she knew; it cannot show that another plan would have saved her.", "limit": "The read stops at three Jenna votes and one Alexis vote. The final 4–1 is reported by TVLine; we have not checked every named ballot.", "history": [ { "episode": 1, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 1, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": { "WORKED": 1, "FAILED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "PE-S51E01-011-INF", "PE-S51E01-015-LEG" ] }, { "episode": 2, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 3, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 4, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 0, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": { "MIXED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "IP04" ] } ], "record_ids": [ "IP04" ], "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-006", "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-019", "EVD-S51E04-020", "EVD-S51E04-033", "EVD-S51E04-034", "EVD-S51E04-035", "EVD-S51E04-037", "EVD-S51E04-040", "EVD-S51E04-044", "EVD-S51E04-045", "EVD-S51E04-046", "EVD-S51E04-047", "EVD-S51E04-048", "EVD-S51E04-049", "EVD-S51E04-050", "EVD-S51E04-051", "EVD-S51E04-052" ] }, { "player": "Kilby", "slug": "kilby", "full_name": "Danny “Kilby” Kilby", "profile": "30 · London, Ontario · Game designer", "portrait": "/images/players/survivor-51/official/kilby.jpg", "tribe": "Dina", "previous_tribe": "Toka", "moved": true, "active": true, "eligible": true, "status": "Still playing", "headline": "Eric offers him a way in.", "summary": "Kilby wants the old Savus to hear what life on Toka felt like to him. Eric says the account makes him want to back Kilby.", "action": "He seeks sympathy, shares interests with Eric and later names their bond the Loverboys.", "result": "Eric offers support. He also reassures Sharonda that their old tie is solid, so a friendship has not yet become a proved flip.", "next_test": "Another decision would have to show how far Eric is willing to go. Dina’s immunity leaves that untested here.", "limit": "The finding stops at Eric’s expressed support. Kilby’s account is not independent proof of mistreatment by the old Toka group.", "history": [ { "episode": 1, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 1, "shared_worked": 1, "outcomes": { "WORKED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "PE-S51E01-003-LEG" ] }, { "episode": 2, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 3, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 4, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 1, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": { "WORKED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "IP01" ] } ], "record_ids": [ "IP01" ], "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-001", "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-012", "EVD-S51E04-014", "EVD-S51E04-027", "EVD-S51E04-028" ] }, { "player": "Kristin", "slug": "kristin", "full_name": "Kristin Flickinger", "profile": "49 · Santa Barbara, California · Crisis management", "portrait": "/images/players/survivor-51/official/kristin.jpg", "tribe": "Toka", "previous_tribe": "Savu", "moved": true, "active": true, "eligible": true, "status": "Still playing", "headline": "Her food lesson lands. Carter still distrusts her.", "summary": "Kristin makes herself useful by pointing out food plants. Carter is focused on a different problem: he remembers being left out of the Savu vote.", "action": "She shares her plant knowledge and separately tries to explain that earlier exclusion to Carter.", "result": "Mike credits her knowledge with helping Toka. Carter still says he distrusts her: practical acceptance and repaired trust have different results.", "next_test": "The food guidance shows a bounded Expert use. Toka’s immunity does not tell us whether it buys her a future vote.", "limit": "Her practical help is counted once, not again as a gift or a second Informational use. Carter’s resistance stays in the record.", "history": [ { "episode": 1, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 1, "shared_worked": 1, "outcomes": { "WORKED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "PE-S51E01-003-LEG" ] }, { "episode": 2, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 3, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 4, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 1, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": { "WORKED": 1, "FAILED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "EX01", "IP02" ] } ], "record_ids": [ "EX01", "IP02" ], "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-016", "EVD-S51E04-017", "EVD-S51E04-018", "EVD-S51E04-031" ] }, { "player": "Lewis", "slug": "lewis", "full_name": "Lewis Kelly", "profile": "28 · Puerto Rico · Farmer", "portrait": "/images/players/survivor-51/official/lewis.jpg", "tribe": "Dina", "previous_tribe": "Toka", "moved": true, "active": true, "eligible": true, "status": "Still playing", "headline": "He is unwell while Dina starts over.", "summary": "Lewis is described as feeling ill while the new tribe builds shelter. A speaker also names him as a possible target if Dina loses.", "action": "His condition and limited camp contribution become part of the tribe’s discussion.", "result": "Dina wins immunity, so the conditional target does not become an actual elimination vote.", "next_test": "Camp recovery and any future targeting would need later evidence.", "limit": "We do not have a diagnosis or a reliable identity for every speaker discussing him. This is context, not a weak-Power finding.", "history": [ { "episode": 1, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 2, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 3, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 4, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] } ], "record_ids": [], "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-002", "EVD-S51E04-003", "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-013", "EVD-S51E04-015" ] }, { "player": "Linnea", "slug": "linnea", "full_name": "Linnea Capobianco", "profile": "25 · Jersey City, New Jersey · Entrepreneur", "portrait": "/images/players/survivor-51/official/linnea.jpg", "tribe": "Dina", "previous_tribe": "Savu", "moved": true, "active": true, "eligible": true, "status": "Still playing", "headline": "The maze produces safety, not a rating.", "summary": "Linnea joins Dina and works the spinning maze with Cristian.", "action": "They complete the challenge first as the new tribe works through the water and maze stages.", "result": "Dina wins immunity and the coffee reward. The result does not establish a separate Expert use without a response to recognized expertise.", "next_test": "Dina’s new relationships still need a game decision to test them.", "limit": "Some observer remarks about Eric and Kilby cannot be assigned reliably to an individual. They are not silently credited to Linnea.", "history": [ { "episode": 1, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 2, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 1, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": { "WORKED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "PE-S51E02-A06-INF" ] }, { "episode": 3, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 4, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] } ], "record_ids": [], "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-031", "EVD-S51E04-032" ] }, { "player": "Maggie", "slug": "maggie", "full_name": "Maggie Nestor", "profile": "40 · Charles Town, West Virginia · Farmer", "portrait": "/images/players/survivor-51/official/maggie.jpg", "tribe": "Toka", "previous_tribe": "Toka", "moved": false, "active": true, "eligible": true, "status": "Still playing", "headline": "She hears Mike’s pitch with Thien An.", "summary": "Maggie takes part in the wary discussion of Mike’s new offers. Thien An still describes her as a close day-one partner.", "action": "She talks through those offers and runs Toka’s maze with Kristin.", "result": "Toka wins the second immunity place. Neither challenge success nor someone else’s trust statement adds a new use to her count.", "next_test": "A later decision would have to test the alliance promises and her carried extra vote.", "limit": "Her extra vote is usable through six players and includes a tie/revote. No new play or verdict on her earlier promise is established.", "history": [ { "episode": 1, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 2, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 3, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 4, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] } ], "record_ids": [], "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-024", "EVD-S51E04-031" ] }, { "player": "Mike", "slug": "mike", "full_name": "Mike Pinsky", "profile": "32 · New York City · Baseball executive", "portrait": "/images/players/survivor-51/official/mike.jpg", "tribe": "Toka", "previous_tribe": "Toka", "moved": false, "active": true, "eligible": true, "status": "Still playing", "headline": "“Open for business” gets a wary reception.", "summary": "Losing Patt leaves Mike looking for a new close ally. Thien An and Maggie hear the broad offers and question why the warmth arrives now.", "action": "He offers personal closeness and says he wants to stay flexible about whom he works with.", "result": "The recorded response is wariness about opportunism, not the dependable commitment he wants. Other replies are more pleasant.", "next_test": "A future Toka vote would have to test his place. Immunity keeps that test out of this episode.", "limit": "The backfire belongs to these recipients. It does not mean everyone rejects him, or that all their distrust starts with this conversation.", "history": [ { "episode": 1, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 2, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 3, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 4, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 0, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": { "BACKFIRED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "REF01" ] } ], "record_ids": [ "REF01" ], "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-001", "EVD-S51E04-016", "EVD-S51E04-017", "EVD-S51E04-023", "EVD-S51E04-024", "EVD-S51E04-029" ] }, { "player": "Ori", "slug": "ori", "full_name": "Ori Jean-Charles", "profile": "27 · Spring Valley, New York · Personal trainer", "portrait": "/images/players/survivor-51/official/ori.jpg", "tribe": "Savu", "previous_tribe": "Savu", "moved": false, "active": true, "eligible": true, "status": "Still playing", "headline": "His loyalties cross the tribe line.", "summary": "Three old Tokas face two old Savus on paper. Ori’s connections make that a poor guide to the choice he says he wants.", "action": "He says Jenna’s position with Devin and Jelly puts her outside his plans too, and names his bond with Alexis as another reason to keep her.", "result": "He explicitly backs Jenna as the target. That response is the Referent finding credited to the relationships he names.", "next_test": "A stated target is narrower than control of a group. His later-reported conversation with Jenna belongs to her dated account.", "limit": "Ori is the responding player in that finding. A gap in his own worked-use count does not mean he lacks influence.", "history": [ { "episode": 1, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 2, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 3, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 4, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] } ], "record_ids": [], "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-009", "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-026", "EVD-S51E04-036", "EVD-S51E04-040", "EVD-S51E04-043" ] }, { "player": "Patt", "slug": "patt", "full_name": "Patt Cannaday", "profile": "33 · Washington, D.C. · Federal prosecutor", "portrait": "/images/players/survivor-51/official/patt.jpg", "tribe": "Toka", "previous_tribe": "Toka", "moved": false, "active": false, "eligible": false, "status": "Earlier exit", "headline": "Her exit still shapes the conversations.", "summary": "Patt left in Episode 3. Jelly’s regret and Mike’s search for a new closest ally show how the others describe the loss.", "action": "There is no new Episode 4 action by Patt to count.", "result": "Her earlier findings and last tribe remain visible in the season record.", "next_test": "Her game has ended; the earlier episode keeps its own evidence boundary.", "limit": "Reactions to Patt are not a second count of her Episode 3 uses or a new named-voter ledger.", "history": [ { "episode": 1, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 2, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": { "WORKED": 2 }, "record_ids": [ "PE-S51E01-010-INF", "PE-S51E01-014-INF" ] }, { "episode": 2, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 3, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 1, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": { "WORKED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "IP01" ] }, { "episode": 4, "status": "PRIOR_EXIT", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] } ], "record_ids": [], "evidence_ids": [] }, { "player": "Rob", "slug": "rob", "full_name": "Rob Antonson", "profile": "40 · Cumberland, Rhode Island · Airline gate agent", "portrait": "/images/players/survivor-51/official/rob.jpg", "tribe": "Savu", "previous_tribe": "Savu", "moved": false, "active": false, "eligible": false, "status": "Left voluntarily · E3", "headline": "His departure leaves seventeen for the draw.", "summary": "Rob left voluntarily in Episode 3. Jeff explains that the planned swap now has seventeen people drawing eighteen buffs.", "action": "There is no new Episode 4 action by Rob in this record.", "result": "His earlier exit affects the arithmetic; it is not another elimination vote.", "next_test": "His game has ended. The earlier source and health limits remain where they were recorded.", "limit": "No diagnosis, revised private motive or new Power use is inferred from the swap.", "history": [ { "episode": 1, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 1, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": { "WORKED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "PE-S51E01-006-INF" ] }, { "episode": 2, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 3, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 4, "status": "PRIOR_EXIT", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] } ], "record_ids": [], "evidence_ids": [] }, { "player": "Sharonda", "slug": "sharonda", "full_name": "Sharonda Cox", "profile": "34 · Richmond, Kentucky · OBGYN resident", "portrait": "/images/players/survivor-51/official/sharonda.jpg", "tribe": "Dina", "previous_tribe": "Savu", "moved": true, "active": true, "eligible": true, "status": "Still playing", "headline": "The Loverboys put her on alert.", "summary": "Sharonda sees Eric getting close to Kilby and worries about the old Savu four. Eric tells her their tie is still solid.", "action": "She asks for reassurance and describes adjusting to the disappointment of starting a new camp.", "result": "She gets an assurance, but the record does not show that her concern disappears. Dina wins immunity.", "next_test": "The friendship and the old group have not yet faced the same vote.", "limit": "No credible threat by Sharonda is established, and being named in the helicopter alliance while absent is not a new response from her.", "history": [ { "episode": 1, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 2, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 1, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": { "WORKED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "PE-S51E02-A07-INF" ] }, { "episode": 3, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 4, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] } ], "record_ids": [], "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-006", "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-026", "EVD-S51E04-028", "EVD-S51E04-029" ] }, { "player": "Thien An", "slug": "thien-an", "full_name": "An “Thien An” Nguyen", "profile": "24 · Fort Worth, Texas · Medical student", "portrait": "/images/players/survivor-51/official/thien-an.jpg", "tribe": "Toka", "previous_tribe": "Toka", "moved": false, "active": true, "eligible": true, "status": "Still playing", "headline": "Mike’s timing makes her wary.", "summary": "Thien An questions Mike’s sudden offers after Patt leaves. She keeps talking with Maggie and builds trust with Carter.", "action": "She discusses Mike’s approach and shares possible targets and assurances with her closer partners.", "result": "The wary response to Mike is recorded. Her own Toka voting preferences do not face a Tribal test this round.", "next_test": "Future cooperation would need to show how those different preferences are resolved.", "limit": "Trust statements and target talk do not establish another counted use by Thien An in this episode.", "history": [ { "episode": 1, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 2, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] }, { "episode": 3, "status": "ASSESSED", "worked": 1, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": { "WORKED": 1, "FAILED": 1 }, "record_ids": [ "IP04", "IP05" ] }, { "episode": 4, "status": "NO_INDIVIDUAL_FINDING", "worked": null, "shared_worked": 0, "outcomes": {}, "record_ids": [] } ], "record_ids": [], "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-003", "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-024", "EVD-S51E04-025", "EVD-S51E04-030" ] } ], "history_records": [ { "id": "PE-S51E01-003-LEG", "episode": 1, "base": "Legitimate", "players": [ "Kristin", "Kilby" ], "shared": true, "effectiveness": "WORKED", "action": "The players accept and complete a joint decision procedure.", "response": "Kilby reports the accepted procedure produced a bond with Kristin.", "consequence": "The procedure resolves the immediate choice and produces a stated relational effect.", "later_account": false, "source_sheet": "26_Power_Effects", "source_row": 5, "source_file": "RPM_Survivor_S51E01_Phase2_Qualitative_Analysis_Candidate_v0_2.xlsx", "title": "Kristin and Kilby follow an agreed way to make their joint choice.", "summary": "The procedure settles the decision, and Kilby says it helped them bond.", "limit": "This is one shared finding. Both cards show it, but it counts as one episode event." }, { "id": "PE-S51E01-005-INF", "episode": 1, "base": "Informational", "players": [ "Devin" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "MIXED", "action": "Devin frames Jenna as untrustworthy and names her as his target.", "response": "Jenna becomes the early named target, but the tribe later moves away from Devin's plan.", "consequence": "His framing contributes to the first viable plan but does not hold the majority.", "later_account": false, "source_sheet": "26_Power_Effects", "source_row": 16, "source_file": "RPM_Survivor_S51E01_Phase2_Qualitative_Analysis_Candidate_v0_2.xlsx", "title": "Devin calls Jenna untrustworthy and pushes her name as the target.", "summary": "Jenna becomes an early target. Later, the tribe turns to Aaliyah.", "limit": "The pitch gained ground at first, then lost it. That mixed result stays out of the worked bars." }, { "id": "PE-S51E01-006-INF", "episode": 1, "base": "Informational", "players": [ "Rob" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "WORKED", "action": "Rob withholds Eric's location, wants the absence to become a larger target, and urges a search.", "response": "Savu members search for Eric and voice suspicion about his absence.", "consequence": "Eric's standing worsens in the presented conversation.", "later_account": false, "source_sheet": "26_Power_Effects", "source_row": 22, "source_file": "RPM_Survivor_S51E01_Phase2_Qualitative_Analysis_Candidate_v0_2.xlsx", "title": "Rob keeps Eric’s location to himself and urges the tribe to look for him.", "summary": "Savu searches for Eric, and players question why he is absent.", "limit": "The count covers the search and suspicion. It doesn’t establish Rob’s control of a later vote." }, { "id": "PE-S51E01-010-INF", "episode": 1, "base": "Informational", "players": [ "Patt" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "WORKED", "action": "Patt tells Jenna she is the target and supplies criticism of Brady.", "response": "Jenna says the warning sends her looking for another target.", "consequence": "Jenna gains actionable information and redirects her next move.", "later_account": true, "source_sheet": "26_Power_Effects", "source_row": 28, "source_file": "RPM_Survivor_S51E01_Phase2_Qualitative_Analysis_Candidate_v0_2.xlsx", "title": "Patt tells Jenna she is a target and passes along criticism of Brady.", "summary": "Jenna says the warning sent her looking for another target.", "limit": "Jenna’s later account helps explain her response. The warning doesn’t give Patt sole credit for the final plan." }, { "id": "PE-S51E01-011-INF", "episode": 1, "base": "Informational", "players": [ "Jenna" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "WORKED", "action": "Jenna tells Brady that Aaliyah criticized his challenge conduct.", "response": "Brady directly links Jenna's information to his desire to target Aaliyah and begins advocating that plan.", "consequence": "Brady's stated target changes; Aaliyah later identifies Jenna's move as part of the shift.", "later_account": true, "source_sheet": "26_Power_Effects", "source_row": 34, "source_file": "RPM_Survivor_S51E01_Phase2_Qualitative_Analysis_Candidate_v0_2.xlsx", "title": "Jenna tells Brady that Aaliyah criticized his behavior in the challenge.", "summary": "Brady says the information makes him want to target Aaliyah and starts arguing for that vote.", "limit": "His stated target changes. The accepted E1 analysis also includes Aaliyah’s later account; it doesn’t identify every voter’s reason." }, { "id": "PE-S51E01-012-INF", "episode": 1, "base": "Informational", "players": [ "Brady" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "MIXED", "action": "Brady commits to Aaliyah and presses the tribe against Devin's Jenna plan.", "response": "Devin resists while the Aaliyah plan remains live and becomes the majority outcome.", "consequence": "Brady contributes to the live alternative that wins, but recipient-by-recipient adoption is not shown.", "later_account": true, "source_sheet": "26_Power_Effects", "source_row": 40, "source_file": "RPM_Survivor_S51E01_Phase2_Qualitative_Analysis_Candidate_v0_2.xlsx", "title": "Brady pushes for Aaliyah while Devin still wants Jenna out.", "summary": "Devin resists. The tribe eventually votes out Aaliyah.", "limit": "Brady’s plan wins the vote, but we can’t follow who accepted his argument. The analysis keeps this result mixed, with later participant context." }, { "id": "PE-S51E01-013-INF", "episode": 1, "base": "Informational", "players": [ "Devin" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "FAILED", "action": "Devin repeatedly asks the tribe to vote Jenna and refuses to switch.", "response": "Brady and the eventual majority do not adopt Devin's target.", "consequence": "His preferred plan loses the bounded reconstruction.", "later_account": false, "source_sheet": "26_Power_Effects", "source_row": 46, "source_file": "RPM_Survivor_S51E01_Phase2_Qualitative_Analysis_Candidate_v0_2.xlsx", "title": "Devin keeps asking the tribe to vote for Jenna and refuses to switch.", "summary": "Brady and the eventual majority don’t follow his plan. Aaliyah leaves.", "limit": "This failed attempt is separate from Devin’s earlier pitch, which had a mixed result." }, { "id": "PE-S51E01-014-INF", "episode": 1, "base": "Informational", "players": [ "Patt" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "WORKED", "action": "Patt publicly identifies Aaliyah as the other person at risk.", "response": "The target becomes public and live whispering follows, but Aaliyah later says she already knew privately.", "consequence": "The information state changes publicly, not as first private notice.", "later_account": true, "source_sheet": "26_Power_Effects", "source_row": 52, "source_file": "RPM_Survivor_S51E01_Phase2_Qualitative_Analysis_Candidate_v0_2.xlsx", "title": "Patt names Aaliyah as the other player at risk during Tribal Council.", "summary": "The target becomes public, and players begin whispering.", "limit": "Aaliyah later said she already knew privately. This count covers the public disclosure, not Patt giving her the first warning." }, { "id": "PE-S51E01-015-LEG", "episode": 1, "base": "Legitimate", "players": [ "Jenna" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "FAILED", "action": "Jenna gives up her ballot to activate the rule-defined chance at safety.", "response": "The formal result is not safe.", "consequence": "A legitimate Power attempt occurs but does not convert into safety.", "later_account": false, "source_sheet": "26_Power_Effects", "source_row": 53, "source_file": "RPM_Survivor_S51E01_Phase2_Qualitative_Analysis_Candidate_v0_2.xlsx", "title": "Jenna gives up her vote to play Shot in the Dark.", "summary": "The result is not safe. The advantage doesn’t protect her.", "limit": "Jenna survives the vote, but that survival isn’t a successful Shot in the Dark." }, { "id": "PE-S51E01-016-LEG", "episode": 1, "base": "Legitimate", "players": [ "Aaliyah" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "FAILED", "action": "Aaliyah gives up her ballot to activate the rule-defined chance at safety.", "response": "The formal result is not safe and Aaliyah remains eligible for elimination.", "consequence": "A legitimate Power attempt occurs but does not convert into safety.", "later_account": true, "source_sheet": "26_Power_Effects", "source_row": 59, "source_file": "RPM_Survivor_S51E01_Phase2_Qualitative_Analysis_Candidate_v0_2.xlsx", "title": "Aaliyah gives up her vote to play Shot in the Dark.", "summary": "The result is not safe, and Aaliyah is voted out.", "limit": "The attempt is counted, but it adds nothing to the worked bars. The accepted E1 analysis also includes her later account." }, { "id": "PE-S51E01-018-REF", "episode": 1, "base": "Referent", "players": [ "Aaliyah" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "WORKED", "action": "Devin's expressed attachment to Aaliyah contributes to his refusal to target her.", "response": "Devin resists Brady's Aaliyah plan and continues pressing Jenna.", "consequence": "Aaliyah retains one ally's protection but not the group majority.", "later_account": false, "source_sheet": "26_Power_Effects", "source_row": 69, "source_file": "RPM_Survivor_S51E01_Phase2_Qualitative_Analysis_Candidate_v0_2.xlsx", "title": "Devin’s attachment to Aaliyah makes him unwilling to target her.", "summary": "He resists Brady’s plan and keeps pushing for Jenna instead.", "limit": "The relationship holds Devin’s loyalty. It doesn’t secure a majority for Aaliyah." }, { "id": "PE-S51E01-019-REF", "episode": 1, "base": "Referent", "players": [ "Devin", "Jelly" ], "shared": true, "effectiveness": "WORKED", "action": "Protective relationships change Aaliyah's own information management and preparation.", "response": "Aaliyah says their protection affected how she concealed closeness and prepared her safety attempt.", "consequence": "A bounded Referent effect is supported for the recipient's behavior.", "later_account": true, "source_sheet": "26_Power_Effects", "source_row": 75, "source_file": "RPM_Survivor_S51E01_Phase2_Qualitative_Analysis_Candidate_v0_2.xlsx", "title": "Devin and Jelly’s protective bonds matter to Aaliyah’s own planning.", "summary": "Aaliyah later says their protection affected how she hid their closeness and prepared her attempt at safety.", "limit": "This is one shared finding from her later account. Devin’s and Jelly’s individual credit can’t be separated." }, { "id": "PE-S51E02-A01-INF", "episode": 2, "base": "Informational", "players": [ "Ana" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "BACKFIRED", "action": "Ana deliberately seeds multiple names to create a rift.", "response": "The names later circulate back as evidence that Ana is naming people.", "consequence": "The maneuver supplies information that later contributes to concern about Ana.", "later_account": false, "source_sheet": "26_Power_Effects", "source_row": 10, "source_file": "RPM_Survivor_S51E02_Phase2_Qualitative_Analysis_Candidate_v0_1.xlsx", "title": "Ana throws out several names to divide the group.", "summary": "Those names come back as evidence that she is talking about other players.", "limit": "The information creates concern about Ana instead of helping her split the group. That is the backfired result." }, { "id": "PE-S51E02-A02-INF", "episode": 2, "base": "Informational", "players": [ "Alexis" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "WORKED", "action": "Alexis spreads that Ana is naming other players.", "response": "Linnea and Sharonda discuss Ana as a concern after the warning circulates.", "consequence": "The information helps create a visible pathway for Ana to become a target.", "later_account": false, "source_sheet": "26_Power_Effects", "source_row": 16, "source_file": "RPM_Survivor_S51E02_Phase2_Qualitative_Analysis_Candidate_v0_1.xlsx", "title": "Alexis tells Linnea and Sharonda that Ana is naming people.", "summary": "They discuss Ana as someone to worry about.", "limit": "The warning helps put Ana under scrutiny. It doesn’t give Alexis sole credit for Ana’s exit." }, { "id": "PE-S51E02-A04-INF", "episode": 2, "base": "Informational", "players": [ "Jelly" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "WORKED", "action": "Jelly discloses the idol to Patt.", "response": "Patt says the disclosure cements the relationship and immediately proposes planning together.", "consequence": "Patt changes the relationship and planning state in the recorded exchange.", "later_account": false, "source_sheet": "26_Power_Effects", "source_row": 28, "source_file": "RPM_Survivor_S51E02_Phase2_Qualitative_Analysis_Candidate_v0_1.xlsx", "title": "Jelly tells Patt about her idol.", "summary": "Patt says it cements their relationship and immediately suggests planning together.", "limit": "The disclosure works in that conversation. Owning the idol is separate, and this response doesn’t prove lasting control of Patt." }, { "id": "PE-S51E02-A05-INF", "episode": 2, "base": "Informational", "players": [ "Ana" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "MIXED", "action": "Ana offers herself as the decoy target for the Eric plan.", "response": "The group accepts Ana's name as the decoy communicated to Eric.", "consequence": "Her proposal works immediately as a decoy but also places her name into the active vote conversation.", "later_account": false, "source_sheet": "26_Power_Effects", "source_row": 34, "source_file": "RPM_Survivor_S51E02_Phase2_Qualitative_Analysis_Candidate_v0_1.xlsx", "title": "Ana offers her own name as a decoy for the plan to vote out Eric.", "summary": "The group accepts the decoy suggestion, which also puts Ana’s name into the vote conversation.", "limit": "The suggestion gets an immediate yes but carries a cost. The analysis keeps the result mixed." }, { "id": "PE-S51E02-A06-INF", "episode": 2, "base": "Informational", "players": [ "Linnea" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "WORKED", "action": "Linnea relays that Ana has been naming players.", "response": "Sharonda adopts the concern and carries Ana's name into the next decision exchange.", "consequence": "The information moves from concern to active target advocacy.", "later_account": false, "source_sheet": "26_Power_Effects", "source_row": 40, "source_file": "RPM_Survivor_S51E02_Phase2_Qualitative_Analysis_Candidate_v0_1.xlsx", "title": "Linnea passes along the concern that Ana is naming people.", "summary": "Sharonda takes the concern seriously and brings Ana’s name into the next target discussion.", "limit": "We can follow that change in Sharonda’s response. It doesn’t identify every voter’s reason." }, { "id": "PE-S51E02-A07-INF", "episode": 2, "base": "Informational", "players": [ "Sharonda" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "WORKED", "action": "Sharonda presents Ana as the majority option and asks Ori to move.", "response": "Ori says he will switch from Eric to Ana.", "consequence": "Ori's stated target position changes in the recorded exchange.", "later_account": false, "source_sheet": "26_Power_Effects", "source_row": 46, "source_file": "RPM_Survivor_S51E02_Phase2_Qualitative_Analysis_Candidate_v0_1.xlsx", "title": "Sharonda tells Ori that Ana is the majority’s target and asks him to switch.", "summary": "Ori says he will change his target from Eric to Ana.", "limit": "His stated choice changes. This finding doesn’t supply a complete ballot map." }, { "id": "IP01", "episode": 3, "base": "Informational", "players": [ "Patt" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "WORKED", "title": "Patt tells Brady about Kilby’s remark", "summary": "Brady says Kilby is treating him like a pawn and wants him out.", "limit": "This explains a change in Brady’s view. It doesn’t make Patt responsible for the whole Kilby plan or tell us how everyone voted.", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E03-011", "EVD-S51E03-012", "EVD-S51E03-026", "EVD-S51E03-029" ] }, { "id": "IP02", "episode": 3, "base": "Informational", "players": [ "Toka clue-discovery group; Lewis reported as bag-searcher; exact relay speaker unresolved" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "WORKED", "title": "Carter’s clue sends the group to the oars", "summary": "After the advantage location becomes known, Brady and Maggie search the oars and retrieve the extra vote.", "limit": "Lewis is reported to have searched the bag, but we can’t identify who relayed the clue. The discovery stays a group finding.", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E03-018", "EVD-S51E03-019", "EVD-S51E03-020" ] }, { "id": "IP03", "episode": 3, "base": "Informational", "players": [ "Devin" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "WORKED", "title": "Devin tells Ori about his advantage", "summary": "Ori says he feels reassured that Devin still remembers their alliance.", "limit": "Ori’s reassurance is clear. A future vote or promise to protect Devin isn’t.", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E03-016" ] }, { "id": "IP04", "episode": 3, "base": "Informational", "players": [ "Thien An" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "WORKED", "title": "Thien An makes the case for Patt", "summary": "She argues that Patt’s ability to connect with people makes her a better target than Mike. The group agrees on Patt.", "limit": "That reasoning is Thien An’s assessment of Patt. The agreement supports her contribution, but the six Patt votes don’t prove she persuaded every voter herself.", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E03-028", "EVD-S51E03-030", "EVD-S51E03-032", "EVD-S51E03-041" ] }, { "id": "IP05", "episode": 3, "base": "Informational", "players": [ "Thien An" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "FAILED", "title": "Thien An warns Brady about Patt", "summary": "Brady hears that Patt is a target but says the plan won’t work. He relies on his expected numbers and dismisses Thien An’s ability to pull it off.", "limit": "We don’t see him pass the warning to Patt. We also can’t say he deliberately sacrificed her or could certainly have saved her.", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E03-031", "EVD-S51E03-041" ] }, { "id": "IP06", "episode": 3, "base": "Informational", "players": [ "Carter" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "FAILED", "title": "Carter downplays the advantage opportunity", "summary": "Brady recognizes that Carter is withholding information. Carter’s denial doesn’t convince him.", "limit": "Brady seeing through this denial doesn’t mean he knew about Carter’s idol or that every part of Carter’s visit failed.", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E03-021" ] }, { "id": "RP01", "episode": 3, "base": "Reward", "players": [ "Brady" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "INDETERMINATE", "title": "Brady trades the extra vote for a promise", "summary": "Maggie promises to vote with Brady, and he hands her the extra vote.", "limit": "We can’t verify Maggie’s ballot or use of the advantage. The promise alone doesn’t tell us whether Brady got the vote he wanted.", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E03-019", "EVD-S51E03-020" ] }, { "id": "REF01", "episode": 3, "base": "Referent", "players": [ "Carter" ], "shared": false, "effectiveness": "WORKED", "title": "Carter finds common ground with Brady", "summary": "Brady identifies with Carter’s farm and football background and offers him an alliance.", "limit": "The offer is the result counted here. It doesn’t prove lasting protection or Carter’s loyalty; the official recap later reports Carter voted for Patt.", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E03-021", "EVD-S51E03-032", "EVD-S51E03-041" ] } ], "sources": [ { "source_id": "S01", "title": "That's the Magic of Survivor", "author_or_speaker": "CBS", "url": "https://www.cbs.com/shows/video/ALVE01M2GC9G58EE1V417N59BGX4HN/", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_EPISODE", "observation_origin_id": "CBS-S51E04-OFFICIAL-CUT", "published_at": "2026-10-14", "publication_precision": "PUBLISHER_DISPLAY_UNLESS_UNKNOWN", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-16T17:33:32+00:00", "first_actual_availability": "NOT_OBSERVED", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "inclusion_status": "INCLUDED", "epistemic_limit": "Official identity and bounded player/caption checks only; no continuous audiovisual review.", "local_text_path": "artifact-work/S01-page.txt", "player_runtime": "01:04:43", "metadata_duration_seconds": 3884, "publisher_media_available_date": "2026-10-14T21:30:00-0700", "metadata_note": "Publisher availability is not observed first working access. Page pubDate/airDate machine values are retained in selected metadata and are not used to infer first availability." }, { "source_id": "S02", "title": "Survivor.S51E04.en original captions", "author_or_speaker": "Subtitle Cat; closing CBS/WGBH caption credit", "url": "https://www.subtitlecat.com/subs/1735/Survivor.S51E04.en-orig.srt", "source_class": "DERIVATIVE_CAPTION_REPRESENTATION", "observation_origin_id": "CBS-S51E04-OFFICIAL-CUT", "published_at": "UNKNOWN", "publication_precision": "PUBLISHER_DISPLAY_UNLESS_UNKNOWN", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-16T17:33:51+00:00", "first_actual_availability": "NOT_OBSERVED", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "inclusion_status": "INCLUDED", "epistemic_limit": "Third-party representation of the edited episode, not an independent witness or a byte-verified official caption download.", "local_text_path": "source/Survivor.S51E04.en-orig.srt", "parent_source_id": "S01", "distribution_page": "https://www.subtitlecat.com/subs/1735/Survivor.S51E04.en.html", "sha256": "f287fbc02ee4ccd4a756f43eb14fb0aebe5790251dc844d29d8e24d68d03f80f", "cue_count": 1667, "first_cue_start": "00:00:03,403", "last_cue_end": "01:04:34,604", "alignment_record": "source/player-alignment.json" }, { "source_id": "S03", "title": "Survivor Season 51 Episode 4 Recap: Who Got Voted Off?", "author_or_speaker": "Doriean Stevenson / Paramount+", "url": "https://www.paramountplus.com/sneak-peak/survivor-season-51-episode-4-recap/", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_EDITORIAL_RECAP", "observation_origin_id": "CBS-PARAMOUNT-S51E04-EDITORIAL", "published_at": "2026-10-15 08:00 AM EST (publisher display)", "publication_precision": "PUBLISHER_DISPLAY_UNLESS_UNKNOWN", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-16T17:33:32+00:00", "first_actual_availability": "NOT_OBSERVED", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "inclusion_status": "INCLUDED", "epistemic_limit": "Formal facts and attributed reporting; same corporate source family as S01. The four read ballots are not a full five-voter ledger.", "local_text_path": "artifact-work/S03-page.txt" }, { "source_id": "S04", "title": "Survivor 51 Recap: The Open Era’s First Tribe Swap Puts Everyone In Danger", "author_or_speaker": "Nick Caruso / TVLine", "url": "https://www.tvline.com/2286901/survivor-51-recap-episode-4-jenna-voted-out-tribe-swap/", "source_class": "INDEPENDENT_WRITTEN_RECONSTRUCTION", "observation_origin_id": "TVLINE-S51E04-RECAP", "published_at": "2026-10-14 9:30 PM EST; updated 2026-10-15 4:12 PM EST (publisher displays)", "publication_precision": "PUBLISHER_DISPLAY_UNLESS_UNKNOWN", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-16T17:33:32+00:00", "first_actual_availability": "NOT_OBSERVED", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "inclusion_status": "INCLUDED", "epistemic_limit": "Formal-result/speaker corroboration at stated precision and wording model. Reconstructs the same broadcast; editorial inevitability and medical claims are not admitted.", "local_text_path": "artifact-work/S04-page.txt" }, { "source_id": "S05", "title": "Episode 4 Recap – Revenge With a Side of Chicken", "author_or_speaker": "Cory Gage / Inside Survivor", "url": "https://insidesurvivor.com/survivor-51-episode-4-recap-revenge-with-a-side-of-chicken-61880", "source_class": "INDEPENDENT_WRITTEN_RECONSTRUCTION", "observation_origin_id": "INSIDE-S51E04-RECAP", "published_at": "2026-10-15 (date only)", "publication_precision": "PUBLISHER_DISPLAY_UNLESS_UNKNOWN", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-16T17:33:32+00:00", "first_actual_availability": "NOT_OBSERVED", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "inclusion_status": "INCLUDED", "epistemic_limit": "Formal-result/speaker corroboration only. Unanimous means the four other castaways voting Jenna; does not mean Jenna cast a self-vote. Commentary, predictions and preview are excluded.", "local_text_path": "artifact-work/S05-page.txt" }, { "source_id": "S06", "title": "Jenna Doore Reveals Deleted Scene That Made Her Feel Safe", "author_or_speaker": "Jenna Doore / Kelli Boyle / TV Insider", "url": "https://www.tvinsider.com/1297405/survivor-51-episode-4-jenna-doore-voted-out-exit-interview/", "source_class": "PARTICIPANT_POSTGAME_INTERVIEW", "observation_origin_id": "PERSPECTIVE-JENNA-DOORE", "published_at": "2026-10-15 12:44 PM (display; timezone unspecified)", "publication_precision": "PUBLISHER_DISPLAY_UNLESS_UNKNOWN", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-16T17:33:32+00:00", "first_actual_availability": "NOT_OBSERVED", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-JENNA-POSTGAME-v01", "inclusion_status": "INCLUDED", "epistemic_limit": "Jenna’s later self-report; unseen conversation is not independently confirmed. Does not prove Ori’s private motive or a lost counterfactual.", "local_text_path": "artifact-work/S06-page.txt", "perspective_origin_id": "PERSPECTIVE-JENNA-DOORE", "hindsight_risk": true, "statement_context_default": "POST_GAME_INTERVIEW" }, { "source_id": "S07", "title": "Survivor 51’s Latest Boot Says Dealing With Devin’s Fixation Was Brutal", "author_or_speaker": "Jenna Doore / Nick Caruso / TVLine", "url": "https://www.tvline.com/2287797/survivor-51-episode-4-jenna-doore-exit-interview/", "source_class": "PARTICIPANT_POSTGAME_INTERVIEW", "observation_origin_id": "PERSPECTIVE-JENNA-DOORE", "published_at": "2026-10-15 12:38 PM EST (publisher display)", "publication_precision": "PUBLISHER_DISPLAY_UNLESS_UNKNOWN", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-16T17:33:32+00:00", "first_actual_availability": "NOT_OBSERVED", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-JENNA-POSTGAME-v01", "inclusion_status": "INCLUDED", "epistemic_limit": "Same participant perspective as S06, not a second island witness. Later explanations and offscreen relationships remain attributed.", "local_text_path": "artifact-work/S07-page.txt", "perspective_origin_id": "PERSPECTIVE-JENNA-DOORE", "hindsight_risk": true, "statement_context_default": "POST_GAME_INTERVIEW" }, { "source_id": "S08", "title": "Survivor 51 episode 4 recap: throw it all away for 3 tribes!", "author_or_speaker": "Andy Dehnart / reality blurred", "url": "https://www.realityblurred.com/realitytv/2026/10/survivor-51-episode-4-thats-magic-survivor-recap/", "source_class": "EDITORIAL_WORDING_MODEL", "observation_origin_id": "REALITYBLURRED-S51E04-EDITORIAL", "published_at": "2026-10-14 (date only)", "publication_precision": "PUBLISHER_DISPLAY_UNLESS_UNKNOWN", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-16T17:33:32+00:00", "first_actual_availability": "NOT_OBSERVED", "evidence_wave_id": null, "inclusion_status": "INCLUDED", "epistemic_limit": "Editorial model only; criticism, jokes, motive claims and comments supply no admitted game facts.", "local_text_path": "artifact-work/S08-page.txt", "admitted_as_game_evidence": false } ], "editorial": { "filter_version": "Workflow/RPM_Public_Language_Filter_v1.md", "proposed_question": "Why did Jenna try to rebuild with Devin and Jelly after they had already voted against her?", "angle_origin": "EXPLICITLY_EVIDENCE_DERIVED_WORKING_QUESTION; same-episode named-author angle in S04 provides editorial context", "public_framing_status": "PROPOSED_FOR_LATER_WORK; JAMES_HAS_NOT_SELECTED_PUBLIC_WORDING", "wording_status": "ORIGINAL_RPM_ADAPTATION_NOT_A_QUOTATION", "evidence_to_test": [ "EVD-S51E04-019", "EVD-S51E04-020", "EVD-S51E04-026", "EVD-S51E04-034", "EVD-S51E04-035", "EVD-S51E04-036", "EVD-S51E04-037", "EVD-S51E04-038", "EVD-S51E04-040", "EVD-S51E04-041", "EVD-S51E04-045" ], "later_question": "What does Jenna’s later account add about the information she thought she had?", "later_evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-047", "EVD-S51E04-048", "EVD-S51E04-049", "EVD-S51E04-050", "EVD-S51E04-051" ], "wording_models": [ { "source_id": "S04", "author": "Nick Caruso", "url": "https://www.tvline.com/2286901/survivor-51-recap-episode-4-jenna-voted-out-tribe-swap/", "excerpt": "I get why she'd want to at least try to fix things there.", "publication_date": "2026-10-14; updated 2026-10-15", "collected_at": "2026-10-16T17:33:32+00:00", "genre": "NAMED_AUTHOR_RECAP", "locator": "The tribe has spoken; paragraph discussing Jenna", "access": "FULL_RELEVANT_ARTICLE_TEXT_INSPECTED", "authorship_basis": "Published byline; no independent human-only production certification performed", "relevance": "Names the practical relationship-repair question and gives a sympathetic specific point of view." }, { "source_id": "S08", "author": "Andy Dehnart", "url": "https://www.realityblurred.com/realitytv/2026/10/survivor-51-episode-4-thats-magic-survivor-recap/", "excerpt": "But Jenna also just went from underdogs flipping the game to being flipped out of the game by the flippin’ producers.", "publication_date": "2026-10-14", "collected_at": "2026-10-16T17:33:32+00:00", "genre": "NAMED_AUTHOR_CRITICISM", "locator": "Opening criticism following fractured original-tribe discussion", "access": "ARTICLE_TEXT_INSPECTED", "authorship_basis": "Published byline and author biography; human-only workflow not independently verified", "relevance": "Concrete player consequence, wordplay and an explicit opinion about the swap; its causal certainty is not imported." } ], "source_to_question_check": "S04 asks why repair was worth trying; proposed question keeps that issue. S08’s swap criticism is a separate causal possibility to test, not an answer.", "audience_prevalence_claim": "NONE", "phase1_editorial_check": "Excerpts checked against inspected text, dates/bylines/access recorded, question origin labeled and games sources kept separate.", "headline": "NOT_DRAFTED_PHASE_1", "answer": "NOT_ANALYZED_PHASE_1", "full_page_language_comparison": "NOT_PERFORMED_PHASE_1; required during authorized Phase 3" }, "attribution_note": "REF02 credits existing Devin/Jelly/Alexis ties for Ori’s stated choice. It is one shared response, not three episode uses. Ori is its responding player.", "counts": { "unit": "Distinct bounded Episode 4 use/attempt/relationship-to-response records; not player strength", "episode": 4, "episode_records": 7, "by_primary_base": { "Informational": 4, "Expert": 1, "Referent": 2 }, "by_effectiveness": { "WORKED": 3, "FAILED": 1, "BACKFIRED": 2, "MIXED": 1 }, "worked_records": [ "IP01", "EX01", "REF02" ], "shared_contribution_rule": "REF02 is one shared recipient effect, not three separate uses; no repeated relay, prior alliance formation, later retelling or secondary-base double count", "later_records_added_to_episode_count": 0, "unqualifying_candidate_note": "No new qualifying Legitimate, Reward or Coercive use established; not zero underlying capacity." }, "formal_outcomes": { "swap": [ 6, 6, 5 ], "first_immunity": "Dina", "second_immunity": "Toka", "tribal": "Savu", "eliminated": "Jenna Doore", "remaining": 16, "directly_captioned_read": { "Jenna": 3, "Alexis": 1, "ballots_read": 4 }, "reported_final_total": { "Jenna": 4, "Alexis": 1, "source_id": "S04", "status": "REPORTED_NOT_FULL_DIRECT_BALLOT_AUDIT" }, "individual_voter_ledger": "NOT_DIRECTLY_VERIFIED", "ordinal_discrepancy": "Host says fifth voted out; there are four vote eliminations plus Rob’s voluntary departure. Name the exit; do not relabel Rob as a vote-out." }, "provenance": { "phase1_aggregate": "087d9b45f746aa9bdae29f7df5d0816dd27ce259292354d2434ddc116182f731", "phase2_aggregate": "d52e275ac714a3ad6907d771c550cdf676b3f5755cb73a98ada1d8770692a15c", "prior_website_base": "4d25332eaa91175159ad91c887ed998207fdaf9e", "historical_checkpoints": "Unchanged E1–E3 page data and finding references from the accepted Episode 3 page", "scoring": "QUALITATIVE_UNCALIBRATED; no player-strength score", "later_interviews": "October 15, one Jenna perspective; outside original Episode count" } }