{ "artifact_id": "RPM-SURVIVOR-S51E04-PHASE1-v0.1", "task_id": "RPM-TASK-20261016-215", "created_at": "2026-10-16T17:42:26+00:00", "phase": "1 — Data Collection", "status": "CHECKED_WITH_EXPLICIT_LIMITATIONS", "show": "Survivor", "season": 51, "episode": 4, "episode_title": "That's the Magic of Survivor", "air_date": "2026-10-14", "mode": "TEXTUAL_EPISODE_RECORD", "calibration": "QUALITATIVE_UNCALIBRATED", "scoring": "GOVERNED_SCORING_DISABLED", "collection_cutoff": "2026-10-16T17:42:26+00:00", "first_actual_caption_availability": "NOT_OBSERVED", "timing_note": "Collected before conservative 2026-10-17T01:30:00Z Eastern broadcast-end-plus-48-hour boundary. This does not claim observed prospective T+0.", "evidence_waves": [ { "id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "boundary": "Released Episode 4 words/actions and bounded formal reporting; no interview hindsight" }, { "id": "EW-S51E04-JENNA-POSTGAME-v01", "boundary": "Jenna October 15 interviews; one participant perspective across two outlets" } ], "sequential_review": { "cue_count": 1667, "reviewed_ranges": [ [ 1, 1667 ] ], "excluded_ranges": [ { "start": 1, "end": 25, "reason": "PRIOR_EPISODE_RECAP_NOT_NEW_E4_EVIDENCE" }, { "start": 186, "end": 189, "reason": "CASTING_PROMOTION" }, { "start": 1654, "end": 1655, "reason": "CAPTION_CREDITS_PROVENANCE_ONLY" }, { "start": 1656, "end": 1660, "reason": "EPISODE_5_PREVIEW_EXCLUDED" } ], "included_exit_comments": [ 1661, 1667 ], "modality_limits": "Complete sequential textual review; no continuous visual/audio review. Uncaptioned content and remaining approximately nine-second tail not fully inspected." }, "source_registry_path": "source/source-registry.json", "editorial_source_notes_path": "source/editorial-source-notes.json", "accepted_input_reuse": { "episode3_phase1_manifest": "outputs/survivor-s51e03-phase1-v01/RPM_Survivor_S51E03_Phase1_Package_v0_1.manifest.json", "episode3_phase1_aggregate": "b14ec314b37a7de52360035a44b589963ad0eeb3c3580c95c31397b8049fcbcd", "episode3_phase2_manifest": "outputs/survivor-s51e03-phase2-v01/RPM_Survivor_S51E03_Phase2_Package_v0_1.manifest.json", "limits": "Episode 2 tally conflict and Episode 3 ballot/resource/context limits remain unchanged. E4 reactions to E3 are new E4 accounts, not predecessor corrections." }, "protected_input_hashes": { "AGENTS.md": "53a7858b15cd606b5385aa1922f83df948a90a1d9aa050e52bf93913f957767d", "Workflow/01 RPM_Data_Collection.md": "6b045c187183958498d620c457f556488e2b4bd2d4efd1b613ac589bc0d3f9df", "Workflow/README.md": "0844052e7da7f61058b791035edcdbc6418b246a6d7f68d6c5c10f742f5e5738", "Workflow/RPM_Public_Language_Filter_v1.md": "c53a99093e46a80d5310a56607940d4120214233627f4416a12e0d09b6b436b7", "outputs/survivor-methodology/RPM_Survivor_Methodology_v1_6.md": "acb0c8544199084d0d97442d53e34a4a7f2c2857a9885f9304919bfeac51cb28", "outputs/survivor-methodology/RPM_Survivor_Season_51_Four_Phase_Runbook_v0_10.md": "02d20cf4f0c398fbd63241e03cc2071ee17bcd751b08a9bb4bf04e8f883a1b28", "outputs/survivor-methodology/RPM_Survivor_Season_51_Constitution_v0_5.md": "c26ac4ce16a77d598953bc8d07cf8cc759cd8dae2a53c1045c0f3a028796e5e7", "outputs/survivor-methodology/RPM_Survivor_Spreadsheet_Information_Specification_v0_6.md": "cc7443b64803a1c438c469824cd6aa039b30b61ddbd0cf9121fd17d03bb9628e", "outputs/survivor-s51e03-phase1-v01/RPM_Survivor_S51E03_Phase1_Package_v0_1.manifest.json": "5fa7ecf9d8131d2e57034cd60613e0e7bdf55d962fbe0662cb4d703d6f591921", "outputs/survivor-s51e03-phase2-v01/RPM_Survivor_S51E03_Phase2_Package_v0_1.manifest.json": "c7cd52a0aa2a53347c87da3db1ef8b04b1a4a5c1093cd33988561d2404880895", "outputs/survivor-s51e03-phase1-v01/RPM_Survivor_S51E03_Phase1_Work_Record_v0_1.md": "9e59755e8a5e98f62d4251f0dab39a9940bca5ad3724024cd07b8421aac5189e", "outputs/survivor-s51e03-phase1-v01/RPM_Survivor_S51E03_Phase1_Data_Check_v0_1.json": "4309c5f40ac60ee69ebcf0cb85112d643fb544525ff89b466c3f609d28bc903e", "outputs/survivor-s51e03-phase1-v01/RPM_Survivor_S51E03_Phase1_Evidence_Set_v0_1.json": "6fcb6fbb808b3d0374d07ec23af7bc4791aa9f99cce40fab6beae25ec8273f31", "outputs/survivor-s51e03-phase1-v01/source/Survivor.S51E03.en-orig.srt": "15ecdde9899cd0fc6258a301c14dd2a74652d92960063357e633024571e609af", "outputs/survivor-s51e03-phase1-v01/source/source-registry.json": "070847b35ec380fda65d2bf1405d74dfd6397ac5bab09fc2a93804e4025231d8", "outputs/survivor-s51e03-phase1-v01/artifact-work/check_evidence.py": "d84d71b1431e91a40da9ec0445180374d70c7d1e9e042cfc18dbfccd02b67642", "outputs/survivor-s51e03-phase1-v01/artifact-work/caption-cues.json": "62b73268c06d9a69dc8a74a122df7c527fcc40993e0777a0232ffe8242427b85", "outputs/survivor-s51e03-phase1-v01/artifact-work/sequential-caption-review.txt": "750c82ab7cd3c77e54de2295559d36c0bd7e8c94480f7df3eea70744a479d3f0", "outputs/survivor-s51e03-phase1-v01/artifact-work/build_evidence.py": "2ac25c4612d62ff0b8783839bacf92c9836414f89bf818ae5a86447b5198b157", "outputs/survivor-s51e03-phase2-v01/check_and_report.py": "d5bfb3d043bffd3baf9c5c82df309123194edac5d60ed584a80332a4932e6d85", "outputs/survivor-s51e03-phase2-v01/build_analysis.py": "fd427db6d0b564c8a211408f793f4fa3c3ea80c5f4cc72b5de95468ce662f81a", "outputs/survivor-s51e03-phase2-v01/RPM_Survivor_S51E03_Phase2_Analysis_Check_v0_1.json": "a20c282cd7c6c8f5be56f2a75ca815974910ddc95ee34a7cfcd6d59aeadbcb16", "outputs/survivor-s51e03-phase2-v01/RPM_Survivor_S51E03_Phase2_Analysis_v0_1.md": "2821c6f955444945d49f588ff6c23bc1288b42b4e1b0b1a8f6c9b1c3cd922a21", "outputs/survivor-s51e03-phase2-v01/RPM_Survivor_S51E03_Phase2_Analysis_Record_v0_1.json": "b34315f60a214a7e3411b3e16260ea12281b86f92609a12016f245770b8fcbf5", "outputs/rpm-naming-migration-2026-08-31/RPM_Methodology_and_Technical_Record_v104.md": "d665727ba0ad1b17b59ba0ffec4c6314bf7185f4a20555d17aab86d838046f9f" }, "authority_availability": { "path": "outputs/rpm-naming-migration-2026-08-31/RPM_Methodology_and_Technical_Record_v104.md", "status": "PRESENT_AND_READ_OCTOBER_16", "correction": "October 12 availability notes said absent; live filesystem check found the 4183-byte file and its full text was inspected. Four-phase routing agrees." }, "evidence": [ { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-001", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-01", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 26, "cue_end": 43, "time_start": "00:01:24,685", "time_end": "00:02:09,830" }, "speakers": [ "Mike (opening question, recap corroborated)", "Kilby", "unresolved responders" ], "recipients": [ "Toka" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "SUBJECT_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "OCCURRENCE", "paraphrase": "Toka discusses the prior result. Kilby reports receiving five votes and criticizes the five-person group’s arithmetic.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Show discussion and attributed reaction only; spoken acknowledgments do not identify a full Episode 3 ballot map." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-002", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-01", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 45, "cue_end": 60, "time_start": "00:02:18,338", "time_end": "00:02:46,800" }, "speakers": [ "Brady" ], "recipients": [], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "SUBJECT_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "OCCURRENCE", "paraphrase": "Brady says Carter and Lewis voted against his side, describes humiliation and says he intends to survive.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "His statements about others remain reports; prior accepted Episode 3 evidence is unchanged." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-003", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-01", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 61, "cue_end": 87, "time_start": "00:02:51,672", "time_end": "00:03:47,627" }, "speakers": [ "Lewis and Thien An (recap attribution)", "unresolved interlocutors" ], "recipients": [ "each other" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "OCCURRENCE", "paraphrase": "Players discuss refusing direction from Brady and the breakup of the five; they describe having more choices.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Claims of holding power are participants’ language, not collected Power findings; individual turns remain partly unresolved." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-004", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-02", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 88, "cue_end": 105, "time_start": "00:03:47,728", "time_end": "00:04:27,667" }, "speakers": [ "Jelly", "unresolved reassuring interlocutor" ], "recipients": [ "Toka interlocutor unresolved" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "Jelly describes regret at not using her idol on Patt, says only Patt knew of it and exempts Devin from people she would target.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Self-report establishes stated knowledge and preference, not omniscient secrecy or a claim she certainly could have saved Patt." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-005", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-03", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 106, "cue_end": 120, "time_start": "00:05:45,912", "time_end": "00:06:24,985" }, "speakers": [ "Alexis (yoga leader, recap corroborated)", "unresolved Savu speaker" ], "recipients": [ "Savu" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "SUBJECT_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "OCCURRENCE", "paraphrase": "Savu does yoga; a speaker describes harmony after losing three people and gaining four chickens.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "A speaker’s assessment is not a measurement of universal trust or leadership." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-006", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-03", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 121, "cue_end": 185, "time_start": "00:06:25,085", "time_end": "00:08:35,948" }, "speakers": [ "Sharonda", "Jenna", "other readers/speakers unresolved" ], "recipients": [ "both tribes" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "Tree mail summons everyone by boat; players separately express frustration, anxiety or hope that circumstances will change.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Do not attribute every reaction or treat anticipated change as an actual merge." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-007", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-04", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 190, "cue_end": 244, "time_start": "00:09:00,540", "time_end": "00:10:50,717" }, "speakers": [ "Jeff", "unresolved players" ], "recipients": [ "all seventeen" ], "statement_context": "FORMAL_HOST_OR_RULE_STATEMENT", "speaker_claim_role": "DIRECT_WITNESS", "claim_function": "FORMAL_RULE_OR_RESULT", "paraphrase": "Jeff describes a possible one-beach game, then expressly says that is not happening today.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": false, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "The host’s setup is not a merge rule; speculative player reactions stay speculative." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-008", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-04", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 247, "cue_end": 277, "time_start": "00:10:54,821", "time_end": "00:11:58,985" }, "speakers": [ "Jeff" ], "recipients": [ "all seventeen" ], "statement_context": "FORMAL_HOST_OR_RULE_STATEMENT", "speaker_claim_role": "DIRECT_WITNESS", "claim_function": "FORMAL_RULE_OR_RESULT", "paraphrase": "Jeff announces two tribes become three by random buff draw; eighteen buffs contain six of each color and seventeen players draw.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": false, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Structural chance allocation, not a player’s social influence; no exact draw probabilities calculated." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-009", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-04", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 278, "cue_end": 284, "time_start": "00:11:59,085", "time_end": "00:12:10,129" }, "speakers": [ "Ori" ], "recipients": [ "Jeff", "all players" ], "statement_context": "TRIBAL_PUBLIC_SPEECH", "speaker_claim_role": "SUBJECT_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "OCCURRENCE", "paraphrase": "Ori says new bonds and plans must be reconsidered after the swap.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "His stated concern does not prove all prior relationships disappear." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-010", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-05", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 299, "cue_end": 378, "time_start": "00:12:33,286", "time_end": "00:15:05,438" }, "speakers": [ "Jeff", "Kristin", "Cristian", "Kilby", "Jelly" ], "recipients": [ "all players" ], "statement_context": "FORMAL_HOST_OR_RULE_STATEMENT", "speaker_claim_role": "DIRECT_WITNESS", "claim_function": "FORMAL_RULE_OR_RESULT", "paraphrase": "Host names all three new rosters: Toka six, Dina six and Savu five; participants describe their starting situations.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": false, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Roster statements are formal; quoted social assessments and optimism do not establish control." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-011", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-05", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 379, "cue_end": 430, "time_start": "00:15:05,538", "time_end": "00:16:49,375" }, "speakers": [ "Jeff", "Cristian (self-reference and recap)", "unresolved Dina speakers" ], "recipients": [ "new tribes" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "Toka and Savu return to their beaches. Dina starts a new camp with pot, machete and flint. Cristian describes a four-person original-Savu majority and possible future targets.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Supply terms and roster are formal; Cristian’s forecast is an attributed intention, not a future vote or proven alliance compliance." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-012", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-06", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 431, "cue_end": 472, "time_start": "00:16:49,475", "time_end": "00:18:07,987" }, "speakers": [ "Kilby", "Dina listeners partly unresolved" ], "recipients": [ "Dina" ], "statement_context": "PLAYER_TO_PLAYER_STRATEGIC_SPEECH", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "Kilby describes old Toka as hostile, says he wants listeners to feel sympathy and interprets reactions as favorable.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Bullying/hostility claims and his reading of reactions remain his account; do not adopt them as findings." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-013", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-06", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 473, "cue_end": 489, "time_start": "00:18:08,988", "time_end": "00:18:50,596" }, "speakers": [ "Lewis", "Dina interlocutors unresolved" ], "recipients": [ "Dina" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "THIRD_PARTY_OBSERVER", "claim_function": "OCCURRENCE", "paraphrase": "Dina discusses shelter construction; Lewis is described as unwell and unable to contribute normally.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "No diagnosis, malingering inference or claim he will be eliminated." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-014", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-06", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 490, "cue_end": 509, "time_start": "00:18:50,696", "time_end": "00:19:30,102" }, "speakers": [ "Eric", "Kilby" ], "recipients": [ "each other" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "RECIPIENT_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "RECIPIENT_EFFECT", "paraphrase": "Eric says he wanted to work with Kilby and that hearing his Toka experience makes him want revenge; they offer mutual support.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Own stated response and promises only; neither a cast ballot nor durable abandonment of Savu is observed." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-015", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-06", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 510, "cue_end": 514, "time_start": "00:19:30,202", "time_end": "00:19:40,746" }, "speakers": [ "unresolved Dina speaker" ], "recipients": [], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "A speaker says Savu should stay together and names Lewis as a possible target if they lose.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Speaker not reliably identified from this text; conditional target, not an actual vote." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-016", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-07", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 515, "cue_end": 546, "time_start": "00:19:55,261", "time_end": "00:21:07,833" }, "speakers": [ "Mike (recap)", "Kristin" ], "recipients": [], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "Mike describes the fractured old-Toka group. Kristin describes her crisis-manager approach to entering a minority position.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Job title and confidence alone establish no recognized authority or expertise effect." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-017", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-07", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 547, "cue_end": 582, "time_start": "00:21:07,933", "time_end": "00:22:11,897" }, "speakers": [ "Kristin", "Mike (later host-addressed confirmation)", "unresolved Toka responders" ], "recipients": [ "Toka" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "RECIPIENT_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "RECIPIENT_EFFECT", "paraphrase": "Kristin points out food plants; recipients ask how she knows and thank her. A speaker credits her with a new food source.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Gratitude and food access do not establish vote protection or group leadership. Mike explicitly corroborates the benefit at 38:19." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-018", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-07", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 583, "cue_end": 620, "time_start": "00:22:11,997", "time_end": "00:23:27,039" }, "speakers": [ "Kristin", "Carter" ], "recipients": [ "each other" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "RECIPIENT_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "RECIPIENT_EFFECT", "paraphrase": "Kristin seeks to rebuild with Carter after leaving him out of the prior vote; Carter says he no longer trusts her and views the approach as tactical.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Carter’s belief is direct for his response, not Kristin’s complete private motive; no future vote follows." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-019", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-08", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 631, "cue_end": 663, "time_start": "00:23:54,133", "time_end": "00:24:56,895" }, "speakers": [ "Alexis", "Jenna" ], "recipients": [ "each other" ], "statement_context": "PLAYER_TO_PLAYER_STRATEGIC_SPEECH", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "OCCURRENCE", "paraphrase": "Alexis looks for divisions. Jenna discusses her poor voting alignment with Devin and Jelly; Alexis reports Devin had targeted Jenna during his visit.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Historical votes/visit speech are participant reports within this episode; no silent rewrite of Episodes 1–3." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-020", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-08", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 664, "cue_end": 700, "time_start": "00:24:56,996", "time_end": "00:26:04,963" }, "speakers": [ "Jenna", "Devin" ], "recipients": [ "each other" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "Jenna describes doubt about Alexis, wants the old-Toka trio together and relays Alexis’s warning. Devin calls the old-Toka option viable while describing distrust of Jenna.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Parallel statements show stated preferences, not sincere agreement or an irrevocable choice." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-021", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-08", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 701, "cue_end": 709, "time_start": "00:26:07,900", "time_end": "00:26:27,886" }, "speakers": [ "Devin", "unresolved respondent" ], "recipients": [ "Jelly" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "Devin describes himself and Jelly as able to choose between Jenna and Alexis.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Actor’s claim of position does not prove exclusive control or recipients’ reasons." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-022", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-09", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 710, "cue_end": 730, "time_start": "00:26:48,073", "time_end": "00:27:26,211" }, "speakers": [ "Kristin", "Brady", "unresolved Toka responders" ], "recipients": [ "Toka" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "SUBJECT_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "OCCURRENCE", "paraphrase": "Kristin discusses the tribe name; Brady says he is reducing his intensity after the prior vote and fears being on the outside again.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Local-language explanation is attributed, not independently fact-checked; private emotions are not inferred from reaction shots." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-023", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-09", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 731, "cue_end": 753, "time_start": "00:27:26,311", "time_end": "00:28:21,233" }, "speakers": [ "Mike", "Kristin", "other Toka recipients partly unresolved" ], "recipients": [ "each other" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "Mike says he needs a new closest ally after Patt and offers himself as available to multiple players.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Pleasant replies and offers do not prove a binding alliance or uniform acceptance." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-024", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-09", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 754, "cue_end": 786, "time_start": "00:28:22,968", "time_end": "00:29:24,363" }, "speakers": [ "Thien An", "Maggie" ], "recipients": [ "each other" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "They criticize Mike’s offers as opportunistic; Thien An calls Maggie her day-one tie and discusses possible alternatives.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "These are players’ judgments, not an editorial character verdict or guaranteed future target." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-025", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-09", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 787, "cue_end": 822, "time_start": "00:29:24,463", "time_end": "00:30:28,660" }, "speakers": [ "Carter", "Thien An" ], "recipients": [ "each other" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "RECIPIENT_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "RELATIONSHIP_EFFECT", "paraphrase": "Carter praises Thien An as rational and seeks a partnership; they discuss Mike versus Kristin and exchange strong trust assurances.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Stated tie, information sharing and target preferences are collected; no tribe-wide reach or tested ballot protection is concluded." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-026", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-10", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 823, "cue_end": 918, "time_start": "00:30:40,305", "time_end": "00:33:42,654" }, "speakers": [ "Ori", "Jelly", "Devin" ], "recipients": [ "each other" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "SUBJECT_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "OCCURRENCE", "paraphrase": "Devin plays matchmaker; Jelly says he embarrasses her. Jelly describes Devin as a close ally and Ori as part of the day-one helicopter group; they reaffirm the tie including absent Sharonda.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Flirting is not assumed to change a vote; Sharonda’s present consent is unobserved. Distinguish Jelly’s irritation from ending her alliance." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-027", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-11", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 931, "cue_end": 989, "time_start": "00:34:16,855", "time_end": "00:36:24,916" }, "speakers": [ "Eric", "Kilby" ], "recipients": [ "each other" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "They bond over shared interests and name the Loverboys; Kilby says he sees Eric as a potential opening in the original-Savu group.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Relationship formation and intended recruitment do not prove Eric has flipped." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-028", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-11", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 990, "cue_end": 1013, "time_start": "00:36:28,953", "time_end": "00:37:18,803" }, "speakers": [ "Sharonda", "Eric", "another Dina observer partly unresolved" ], "recipients": [ "each other" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "RECIPIENT_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "RECIPIENT_EFFECT", "paraphrase": "Concern is expressed about Eric’s closeness to Kilby; Eric reassures Sharonda that their old tie remains solid.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Do not assign each unidentified observer turn or conclude the reassurance removed her concern." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-029", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-12", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 1014, "cue_end": 1051, "time_start": "00:37:35,420", "time_end": "00:39:07,545" }, "speakers": [ "Jeff", "Mike", "Sharonda" ], "recipients": [ "all tribes" ], "statement_context": "TRIBAL_PUBLIC_SPEECH", "speaker_claim_role": "RECIPIENT_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "RECIPIENT_EFFECT", "paraphrase": "Mike explicitly credits Kristin’s food knowledge with helping Toka; Sharonda describes recovering from disappointment about starting over.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Useful knowledge and personal adjustment are recorded without a Power classification." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-030", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-12", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 1052, "cue_end": 1096, "time_start": "00:39:11,349", "time_end": "00:41:17,809" }, "speakers": [ "Jeff" ], "recipients": [ "all tribes" ], "statement_context": "FORMAL_HOST_OR_RULE_STATEMENT", "speaker_claim_role": "DIRECT_WITNESS", "claim_function": "FORMAL_RULE_OR_RESULT", "paraphrase": "Challenge uses bucket-passed water then a two-person spinning maze. First two tribes win immunity; first gets a coffee kit and second iced coffee. Thien An and Eric sit out.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": false, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Record rules and formal safety separately from social influence." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-031", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-12", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 1097, "cue_end": 1243, "time_start": "00:41:17,909", "time_end": "00:46:16,207" }, "speakers": [ "Jeff", "named competitors", "unresolved callers" ], "recipients": [ "competing tribes" ], "statement_context": "FORMAL_HOST_OR_RULE_STATEMENT", "speaker_claim_role": "DIRECT_WITNESS", "claim_function": "OCCURRENCE", "paraphrase": "Host describes Toka/Dina progressing and Savu struggling. Maggie and Kristin run Toka’s maze; Linnea and Cristian run Dina’s. A request to stop talking is followed by assent.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": false, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Only named roles are assigned; the stop-talking speaker/recipient is not established here. Individual tactical skill is not automatically Expert Power." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-032", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-12", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 1244, "cue_end": 1304, "time_start": "00:46:16,307", "time_end": "00:48:19,764" }, "speakers": [ "Jeff" ], "recipients": [ "Dina", "Toka", "Savu" ], "statement_context": "FORMAL_HOST_OR_RULE_STATEMENT", "speaker_claim_role": "DIRECT_WITNESS", "claim_function": "FORMAL_RULE_OR_RESULT", "paraphrase": "Dina wins first. Toka finishes second even though its ball falls out after the maze; Jeff says completing the maze counts. Savu must attend Tribal.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": false, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Formal ruling and rewards are corroborated; challenge victory is not a social Power finding." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-033", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-13", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 1305, "cue_end": 1332, "time_start": "00:48:19,864", "time_end": "00:49:49,920" }, "speakers": [ "Jenna", "Devin", "unresolved Savu responders" ], "recipients": [ "Savu" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "Jenna questions whether Devin and Jelly can be trusted. Devin prepares a chicken and says he privately named it Jenna while weighing the two targets.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Naming the chicken is Devin’s own account; not a communicated threat or evidence of Jenna hearing it." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-034", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-13", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 1333, "cue_end": 1359, "time_start": "00:49:50,020", "time_end": "00:50:47,244" }, "speakers": [ "Jenna", "Devin/Jelly recipients with some turns unresolved" ], "recipients": [ "each other" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "Jenna pitches staying Toka together, treating Ori as valuable and targeting Alexis; she describes that as her voting plan.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Her confidence and conversational assent are not sincere commitments from Devin/Jelly." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-035", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-14", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 1360, "cue_end": 1403, "time_start": "00:50:49,813", "time_end": "00:52:23,841" }, "speakers": [ "Alexis", "Jenna" ], "recipients": [ "each other" ], "statement_context": "PLAYER_TO_PLAYER_STRATEGIC_SPEECH", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "Alexis warns Jenna against Devin/Jelly and asks for shoes as collateral. Jenna refuses and says she intends to vote Alexis.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "No shoes transfer occurs. An intended assurance device is not an enforced bargain or changed vote." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-036", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-15", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 1404, "cue_end": 1419, "time_start": "00:52:26,310", "time_end": "00:52:56,306" }, "speakers": [ "Ori", "Devin (dialogue partner; some turns unresolved)" ], "recipients": [ "each other" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "Ori says his helicopter tie with Devin/Jelly and his relationship with Alexis lead him to want Jenna out; conversation agrees on Jenna.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Direct for Ori’s stated reasons, not the complete private reasoning of every voter; actual ballot identities require separate evidence." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-037", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-15", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 1420, "cue_end": 1445, "time_start": "00:52:56,407", "time_end": "00:53:49,159" }, "speakers": [ "Jenna", "Jelly", "Devin partly unresolved" ], "recipients": [ "each other" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "RECIPIENT_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "RECIPIENT_EFFECT", "paraphrase": "Jenna relays Alexis’s arguments. Jelly reacts against Alexis describing her and Devin as threats.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Recorded reaction is not proof that Jelly ultimately votes Alexis." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-038", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-15", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 1446, "cue_end": 1458, "time_start": "00:53:53,363", "time_end": "00:54:21,391" }, "speakers": [ "Jelly", "Devin partly unresolved" ], "recipients": [ "each other" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "Jelly calls Alexis a poor longer-term ally but worries that targeting her would upset Ori and fracture the helicopter alliance.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Own stated tradeoff, not sole-cause proof or independent evidence of Ori’s unspoken feelings." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-039", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-15", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 1459, "cue_end": 1476, "time_start": "00:54:24,528", "time_end": "00:55:04,268" }, "speakers": [ "Devin", "Savu dinner participants" ], "recipients": [ "Savu" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "At the meal Devin weighs the original-Toka numbers against prior conflict with Jenna and new worries about Alexis.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Narrative suspense does not establish when his final decision was made or that every option was equally live." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-040", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-16", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 1477, "cue_end": 1519, "time_start": "00:55:32,863", "time_end": "00:57:04,021" }, "speakers": [ "Jeff", "Ori", "Jenna", "Alexis" ], "recipients": [ "Tribal Council" ], "statement_context": "TRIBAL_PUBLIC_SPEECH", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "Ori discusses finding a crack in the three original Tokas; Jenna notes Devin/Jelly had voted her before; Alexis argues each player has an individual game.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Public advocacy can be strategic; the apparent three-to-two split is not a full alliance map." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-041", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-16", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 1520, "cue_end": 1541, "time_start": "00:57:04,121", "time_end": "00:57:53,337" }, "speakers": [ "Jelly" ], "recipients": [ "Tribal Council" ], "statement_context": "TRIBAL_PUBLIC_SPEECH", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "Jelly contrasts familiarity with Jenna against limited time with Ori/Alexis and describes weighing familiar versus unfamiliar risk.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Public framing does not erase her separately recorded day-one connection with Ori." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-042", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-16", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 1542, "cue_end": 1572, "time_start": "00:57:53,437", "time_end": "00:59:03,173" }, "speakers": [ "Alexis", "Jelly", "Jeff" ], "recipients": [ "Tribal Council" ], "statement_context": "TRIBAL_PUBLIC_SPEECH", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "Alexis offers lasting loyalty to anyone voting with her; Jelly calls stability appealing while questioning whether it is merely charm.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Offer and stated doubt only; no accepted contract or durable compliance follows from this speech." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-043", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-16", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 1573, "cue_end": 1619, "time_start": "00:59:03,273", "time_end": "01:00:43,440" }, "speakers": [ "Ori", "Devin", "Alexis", "Jelly", "Jeff" ], "recipients": [ "Tribal Council" ], "statement_context": "TRIBAL_PUBLIC_SPEECH", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "Ori urges a departure from original-tribe arithmetic; Devin talks about repairing cracks and a simple route; Alexis urges risk and Jelly responds with a church analogy.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Collect speeches and their intended appeals without attributing the final vote to one speech." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-044", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-17", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 1620, "cue_end": 1630, "time_start": "01:00:44,708", "time_end": "01:01:28,885" }, "speakers": [ "Jeff", "two voting speakers unresolved" ], "recipients": [ "voters" ], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "Voting begins; one speaker names an unnamed threat and another explicitly apologizes to Jenna, citing distrust.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "No unseen parchment/speaker assignment. Ballot captions alone do not establish a complete named voter ledger." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-045", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-17", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 1631, "cue_end": 1653, "time_start": "01:01:43,400", "time_end": "01:03:32,976" }, "speakers": [ "Jeff" ], "recipients": [ "Savu" ], "statement_context": "FORMAL_HOST_OR_RULE_STATEMENT", "speaker_claim_role": "DIRECT_WITNESS", "claim_function": "FORMAL_RULE_OR_RESULT", "paraphrase": "After the advantage invitation, Jeff reads Alexis, Jenna, Jenna, Jenna and stops at three; Jenna leaves.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": false, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "This is a three-to-one read of four ballots. TVLine reports a four-to-one final total; do not call the unread fifth ballot directly observed." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-046", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-18", "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-EPISODE-v01", "source_ids": [ "S02" ], "locator": { "cue_start": 1661, "cue_end": 1667, "time_start": "01:04:16,186", "time_end": "01:04:34,604" }, "speakers": [ "Jenna" ], "recipients": [], "statement_context": "CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE", "speaker_claim_role": "SUBJECT_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "OCCURRENCE", "paraphrase": "Jenna’s included exit comments describe feeling blindsided and hurt while proud she played wholeheartedly.", "attribution_basis": "Caption names/address/self-reference or cited recap; unresolved turns are explicitly retained. Italics alone do not establish camera context.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_TEXT", "statement_content_truth_status": "LIMITED_TO_SPEAKER_ROLE_AND_RECORDED_PRECISION", "interview_timing_status": "EPISODE_RELEASED_RECORD", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": "NO_POSTGAME_KNOWLEDGE_ADMITTED", "epistemic_limit": "Exit comments belong to this episode cut after the preview; they do not supply unseen pre-vote information." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-047", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-19", "source_ids": [ "S06" ], "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-JENNA-POSTGAME-v01", "locator": { "article_section": "Did you really trust Jelly / following corroboration answer" }, "speakers": [ "Jenna Doore" ], "recipients": [ "interviewer" ], "statement_context": "POST_GAME_INTERVIEW", "speaker_claim_role": "SUBJECT_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "RETROSPECTIVE_CONTEXT", "paraphrase": "Jenna says she checked Alexis’s warning with Ori, he did not confirm it, and she concluded Alexis was making up danger. She says she did not know the helicopter alliance.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_INTERVIEW", "statement_content_truth_status": "ATTRIBUTED_PARTICIPANT_ACCOUNT", "interview_timing_status": "POST_GAME_PUBLISHED_2026-10-15", "perspective_origin_id": "PERSPECTIVE-JENNA-DOORE", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": true, "epistemic_limit": "Unshown conversation is Jenna’s later account; do not insert it into the original caption record or infer Ori’s private motive." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-048", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-19", "source_ids": [ "S06" ], "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-JENNA-POSTGAME-v01", "locator": { "article_section": "Deep conversations and relationship repair with Devin" }, "speakers": [ "Jenna Doore" ], "recipients": [ "interviewer" ], "statement_context": "POST_GAME_INTERVIEW", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "Jenna describes repairing a personal relationship with Devin and wanting to keep working options open rather than cut him off.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_INTERVIEW", "statement_content_truth_status": "ATTRIBUTED_PARTICIPANT_ACCOUNT", "interview_timing_status": "POST_GAME_PUBLISHED_2026-10-15", "perspective_origin_id": "PERSPECTIVE-JENNA-DOORE", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": true, "epistemic_limit": "Direct for her later explanation of intent, not proof of Devin’s sincere commitment." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-049", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-19", "source_ids": [ "S06" ], "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-JENNA-POSTGAME-v01", "locator": { "article_section": "Shoes as collateral" }, "speakers": [ "Jenna Doore" ], "recipients": [ "interviewer" ], "statement_context": "POST_GAME_INTERVIEW", "speaker_claim_role": "ACTOR_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "ACTOR_INTENT", "paraphrase": "Jenna says she withheld shoes because she planned to vote Alexis and thought the demand could expose her lack of commitment.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_INTERVIEW", "statement_content_truth_status": "ATTRIBUTED_PARTICIPANT_ACCOUNT", "interview_timing_status": "POST_GAME_PUBLISHED_2026-10-15", "perspective_origin_id": "PERSPECTIVE-JENNA-DOORE", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": true, "epistemic_limit": "Own later reason only; not evidence that Alexis decoded it at the time." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-050", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-19", "source_ids": [ "S06" ], "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-JENNA-POSTGAME-v01", "locator": { "article_section": "Why was it clear / conversation about getting Jelly out" }, "speakers": [ "Jenna Doore" ], "recipients": [ "interviewer" ], "statement_context": "POST_GAME_INTERVIEW", "speaker_claim_role": "SUBJECT_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "RETROSPECTIVE_CONTEXT", "paraphrase": "Jenna says she understood the options as Alexis or Jelly, and describes an unshown Jelly-target conversation involving Ori/Alexis.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_INTERVIEW", "statement_content_truth_status": "ATTRIBUTED_PARTICIPANT_ACCOUNT", "interview_timing_status": "POST_GAME_PUBLISHED_2026-10-15", "perspective_origin_id": "PERSPECTIVE-JENNA-DOORE", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": true, "epistemic_limit": "Not an established executable majority or proof the counterplan would succeed; later knowledge remains separate." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-051", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-19", "source_ids": [ "S07" ], "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-JENNA-POSTGAME-v01", "locator": { "article_section": "Heading into Tribal / corroboration with Ori" }, "speakers": [ "Jenna Doore" ], "recipients": [ "interviewer" ], "statement_context": "POST_GAME_INTERVIEW", "speaker_claim_role": "SUBJECT_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "RETROSPECTIVE_CONTEXT", "paraphrase": "Jenna says this was her most confident Tribal, repeats the missing-helicopter-information explanation and says she expected Alexis or Jelly to leave.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_INTERVIEW", "statement_content_truth_status": "ATTRIBUTED_PARTICIPANT_ACCOUNT", "interview_timing_status": "POST_GAME_PUBLISHED_2026-10-15", "perspective_origin_id": "PERSPECTIVE-JENNA-DOORE", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": true, "epistemic_limit": "Duplicates S06’s participant perspective, not independent corroboration; reporter’s four-vote statement is separately classified reporting." }, { "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E04-052", "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-19", "source_ids": [ "S07" ], "evidence_wave_id": "EW-S51E04-JENNA-POSTGAME-v01", "locator": { "article_section": "What would have been your vision without the swap" }, "speakers": [ "Jenna Doore" ], "recipients": [ "interviewer" ], "statement_context": "POST_GAME_INTERVIEW", "speaker_claim_role": "SUBJECT_SELF_REPORT", "claim_function": "RETROSPECTIVE_CONTEXT", "paraphrase": "Jenna describes promising ties with Lewis and Thien An and wonders what might have happened without the swap.", "statement_occurrence_status": "PRESENT_IN_REVIEWED_INTERVIEW", "statement_content_truth_status": "ATTRIBUTED_PARTICIPANT_ACCOUNT", "interview_timing_status": "POST_GAME_PUBLISHED_2026-10-15", "perspective_origin_id": "PERSPECTIVE-JENNA-DOORE", "strategic_performance_risk": true, "hindsight_risk": true, "epistemic_limit": "Counterfactual and own relationship assessment only. Earlier episode state and conclusions are not revised." } ], "events": [ { "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-01", "label": "Prior Tribal aftermath", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-001", "EVD-S51E04-002", "EVD-S51E04-003" ], "order_basis": "RELEASED_EDIT_ORDER_NOT_COMPLETE_ISLAND_CHRONOLOGY", "power_analysis": "NOT_PERFORMED_PHASE_1" }, { "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-02", "label": "Jelly idol and stated loyalty", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-004" ], "order_basis": "RELEASED_EDIT_ORDER_NOT_COMPLETE_ISLAND_CHRONOLOGY", "power_analysis": "NOT_PERFORMED_PHASE_1" }, { "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-03", "label": "Pre-swap camp and summons", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-005", "EVD-S51E04-006" ], "order_basis": "RELEASED_EDIT_ORDER_NOT_COMPLETE_ISLAND_CHRONOLOGY", "power_analysis": "NOT_PERFORMED_PHASE_1" }, { "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-04", "label": "Host swap procedure", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-007", "EVD-S51E04-008", "EVD-S51E04-009" ], "order_basis": "RELEASED_EDIT_ORDER_NOT_COMPLETE_ISLAND_CHRONOLOGY", "power_analysis": "NOT_PERFORMED_PHASE_1" }, { "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-05", "label": "New rosters and starting supplies", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-011" ], "order_basis": "RELEASED_EDIT_ORDER_NOT_COMPLETE_ISLAND_CHRONOLOGY", "power_analysis": "NOT_PERFORMED_PHASE_1" }, { "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-06", "label": "Dina integration and illness", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-012", "EVD-S51E04-013", "EVD-S51E04-014", "EVD-S51E04-015" ], "order_basis": "RELEASED_EDIT_ORDER_NOT_COMPLETE_ISLAND_CHRONOLOGY", "power_analysis": "NOT_PERFORMED_PHASE_1" }, { "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-07", "label": "Kristin’s Toka integration", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-016", "EVD-S51E04-017", "EVD-S51E04-018" ], "order_basis": "RELEASED_EDIT_ORDER_NOT_COMPLETE_ISLAND_CHRONOLOGY", "power_analysis": "NOT_PERFORMED_PHASE_1" }, { "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-08", "label": "Alexis/Jenna and old-Toka pitch", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-019", "EVD-S51E04-020", "EVD-S51E04-021" ], "order_basis": "RELEASED_EDIT_ORDER_NOT_COMPLETE_ISLAND_CHRONOLOGY", "power_analysis": "NOT_PERFORMED_PHASE_1" }, { "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-09", "label": "Toka relationship offers", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-022", "EVD-S51E04-023", "EVD-S51E04-024", "EVD-S51E04-025" ], "order_basis": "RELEASED_EDIT_ORDER_NOT_COMPLETE_ISLAND_CHRONOLOGY", "power_analysis": "NOT_PERFORMED_PHASE_1" }, { "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-10", "label": "Savu social and helicopter ties", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-026" ], "order_basis": "RELEASED_EDIT_ORDER_NOT_COMPLETE_ISLAND_CHRONOLOGY", "power_analysis": "NOT_PERFORMED_PHASE_1" }, { "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-11", "label": "Loverboys and original-Savu concern", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-027", "EVD-S51E04-028" ], "order_basis": "RELEASED_EDIT_ORDER_NOT_COMPLETE_ISLAND_CHRONOLOGY", "power_analysis": "NOT_PERFORMED_PHASE_1" }, { "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-12", "label": "Challenge and ruling", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-029", "EVD-S51E04-030", "EVD-S51E04-031", "EVD-S51E04-032" ], "order_basis": "RELEASED_EDIT_ORDER_NOT_COMPLETE_ISLAND_CHRONOLOGY", "power_analysis": "NOT_PERFORMED_PHASE_1" }, { "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-13", "label": "Savu preparation and Jenna pitch", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-033", "EVD-S51E04-034" ], "order_basis": "RELEASED_EDIT_ORDER_NOT_COMPLETE_ISLAND_CHRONOLOGY", "power_analysis": "NOT_PERFORMED_PHASE_1" }, { "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-14", "label": "Alexis warning and collateral request", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-035" ], "order_basis": "RELEASED_EDIT_ORDER_NOT_COMPLETE_ISLAND_CHRONOLOGY", "power_analysis": "NOT_PERFORMED_PHASE_1" }, { "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-15", "label": "Private voting options and stated tradeoffs", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-036", "EVD-S51E04-037", "EVD-S51E04-038", "EVD-S51E04-039" ], "order_basis": "RELEASED_EDIT_ORDER_NOT_COMPLETE_ISLAND_CHRONOLOGY", "power_analysis": "NOT_PERFORMED_PHASE_1" }, { "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-16", "label": "Tribal advocacy", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-040", "EVD-S51E04-041", "EVD-S51E04-042", "EVD-S51E04-043" ], "order_basis": "RELEASED_EDIT_ORDER_NOT_COMPLETE_ISLAND_CHRONOLOGY", "power_analysis": "NOT_PERFORMED_PHASE_1" }, { "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-17", "label": "Vote and elimination", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-044", "EVD-S51E04-045" ], "order_basis": "RELEASED_EDIT_ORDER_NOT_COMPLETE_ISLAND_CHRONOLOGY", "power_analysis": "NOT_PERFORMED_PHASE_1" }, { "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-18", "label": "Included exit remarks", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-046" ], "order_basis": "RELEASED_EDIT_ORDER_NOT_COMPLETE_ISLAND_CHRONOLOGY", "power_analysis": "NOT_PERFORMED_PHASE_1" }, { "event_id": "EVT-S51E04-19", "label": "Separate October 15 Jenna perspective", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-047", "EVD-S51E04-048", "EVD-S51E04-049", "EVD-S51E04-050", "EVD-S51E04-051", "EVD-S51E04-052" ], "order_basis": "LATER_PUBLICATION", "power_analysis": "NOT_PERFORMED_PHASE_1" } ], "formal_resources": [ { "resource_id": "FR01", "resource": "Jelly’s carried idol", "rule": "Exact accepted prior idol rules; no new expiry invented", "access": "Inherited possession; Jelly again self-reports it", "activation": "NO_NEW_ACTIVATION_CONFIRMED", "deployment": "NO_IDOL_PLAY_RECORDED", "formal_response": "NO_FORMAL_CHANGE_RECORDED", "human_response": "Jelly regrets prior nonuse and says Patt alone knew", "group_response": "UNOBSERVED", "cost": "NO_NEW_CONFIRMED_COST", "conversion": "NONE_CONFIRMED", "expiry": "BY_PRIOR_ACCEPTED_REFERENCE", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-004", "EVD-S51E04-045" ], "power_base_interpretation": "DEFERRED_TO_PHASE_2" }, { "resource_id": "FR02", "resource": "Devin’s carried extra vote", "rule": "Inherited Episode 3 FR02; do not copy Maggie’s expiry terms", "access": "Prior acquired access; Jenna later refers to it", "activation": "NO_NEW_ACTIVATION_CONFIRMED", "deployment": "NO_EXTRA_VOTE_USE_CONFIRMED", "formal_response": "NO_NEW_CONFIRMED_CHANGE", "human_response": "Later Jenna discusses her calculation", "group_response": "UNOBSERVED", "cost": "NO_NEW_CONFIRMED_COST", "conversion": "UNOBSERVED", "expiry": "UNRESOLVED_BY_PRIOR_RECORD", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-045", "EVD-S51E04-051" ], "power_base_interpretation": "DEFERRED_TO_PHASE_2" }, { "resource_id": "FR03", "resource": "Maggie’s carried extra vote", "rule": "Inherited Episode 3 FR03: usable through six, includes tie/revote", "access": "Prior accepted transfer from Brady", "activation": "NO_NEW_ACTIVATION_CONFIRMED", "deployment": "TOKA_DOES_NOT_ATTEND_TRIBAL", "formal_response": "NO_NEW_CONFIRMED_CHANGE", "human_response": "UNOBSERVED", "group_response": "UNOBSERVED", "cost": "NO_NEW_CONFIRMED_COST", "conversion": "UNOBSERVED", "expiry": "SIX_REMAINING", "evidence_ids": [], "power_base_interpretation": "DEFERRED_TO_PHASE_2", "accepted_input_reference": "Episode 3 FR03" }, { "resource_id": "FR04", "resource": "Carter’s carried idol", "rule": "Inherited Episode 3 FR01; expiry unresolved", "access": "Prior accepted Rob transfer", "activation": "NO_NEW_ACTIVATION_CONFIRMED", "deployment": "TOKA_DOES_NOT_ATTEND_TRIBAL", "formal_response": "NO_NEW_CONFIRMED_CHANGE", "human_response": "UNOBSERVED", "group_response": "UNOBSERVED", "cost": "NO_NEW_CONFIRMED_COST", "conversion": "UNOBSERVED", "expiry": "UNKNOWN", "evidence_ids": [], "power_base_interpretation": "DEFERRED_TO_PHASE_2", "accepted_input_reference": "Episode 3 FR01" }, { "resource_id": "FR05", "resource": "Tribe assignment and Dina supplies", "rule": "Eighteen buffs, seventeen draws; Dina gets pot, machete, flint", "access": "All seventeen draw under host procedure", "activation": "BUFF_DRAW_COMPLETED", "deployment": "THREE_ROSTERS_FORMED", "formal_response": "TOKA_6_DINA_6_SAVU_5", "human_response": "Separate stated hope/anxiety", "group_response": "ROSTERS_ACCEPTED", "cost": "Prior camp/group disrupted; Dina builds shelter", "conversion": "NEW_MEMBERSHIPS", "expiry": "UNTIL_LATER_CHANGE", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-008", "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-011" ], "power_base_interpretation": "DEFERRED_TO_PHASE_2" }, { "resource_id": "FR06", "resource": "Episode 4 immunity and reward", "rule": "First two safe; first coffee kit, second iced coffee", "access": "All three tribes compete; Thien An and Eric sit out", "activation": "CHALLENGE_COMPLETED", "deployment": "DINA_FIRST_TOKA_SECOND", "formal_response": "DINA_TOKA_SAFE_SAVU_TRIBAL", "human_response": "Recorded congratulations and cooperation", "group_response": "RESULT_ACCEPTED", "cost": "Challenge effort", "conversion": "EPISODE_SAFETY_AND_REWARD", "expiry": "EPISODE_4_TRIBAL", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-030", "EVD-S51E04-031", "EVD-S51E04-032" ], "power_base_interpretation": "DEFERRED_TO_PHASE_2" }, { "resource_id": "FR07", "resource": "Jenna’s spent Shot in the Dark", "rule": "Prior used resource; no restoration established", "access": "NO_NEW_ACCESS_ESTABLISHED", "activation": "NOT_AVAILABLE_AS_ASSURANCE", "deployment": "NO_NEW_PLAY_RECORDED", "formal_response": "NO_NEW_CONFIRMED_CHANGE", "human_response": "S05 reports no remaining die to lend", "group_response": "UNOBSERVED", "cost": "PRIOR_COST_NOT_REASSESSED", "conversion": "NONE_CONFIRMED", "expiry": "PRIOR_USE_PRESERVED", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-035" ], "power_base_interpretation": "DEFERRED_TO_PHASE_2", "detail_basis": "S05 reporting; exact prior rules by accepted reference" } ], "rosters_after_swap": { "Toka": [ "Mike", "Carter", "Brady", "Thien An", "Kristin", "Maggie" ], "Dina": [ "Kilby", "Lewis", "Sharonda", "Eric", "Linnea", "Cristian" ], "Savu": [ "Jelly", "Devin", "Jenna", "Ori", "Alexis" ] }, "player_coverage": [ { "player": "Mike", "status": "ACTIVE_AT_EPISODE_START", "roster": "Toka", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-001", "EVD-S51E04-016", "EVD-S51E04-017", "EVD-S51E04-023", "EVD-S51E04-024", "EVD-S51E04-029" ], "coverage_limit": "Only identified Episode evidence or formal roster; no missingness-to-weakness inference" }, { "player": "Carter", "status": "ACTIVE_AT_EPISODE_START", "roster": "Toka", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-002", "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-018", "EVD-S51E04-025" ], "coverage_limit": "Only identified Episode evidence or formal roster; no missingness-to-weakness inference" }, { "player": "Brady", "status": "ACTIVE_AT_EPISODE_START", "roster": "Toka", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-002", "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-022" ], "coverage_limit": "Only identified Episode evidence or formal roster; no missingness-to-weakness inference" }, { "player": "Thien An", "status": "ACTIVE_AT_EPISODE_START", "roster": "Toka", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-003", "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-024", "EVD-S51E04-025", "EVD-S51E04-030" ], "coverage_limit": "Only identified Episode evidence or formal roster; no missingness-to-weakness inference" }, { "player": "Kristin", "status": "ACTIVE_AT_EPISODE_START", "roster": "Toka", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-016", "EVD-S51E04-017", "EVD-S51E04-018", "EVD-S51E04-031" ], "coverage_limit": "Only identified Episode evidence or formal roster; no missingness-to-weakness inference" }, { "player": "Maggie", "status": "ACTIVE_AT_EPISODE_START", "roster": "Toka", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-024", "EVD-S51E04-031" ], "coverage_limit": "Only identified Episode evidence or formal roster; no missingness-to-weakness inference" }, { "player": "Kilby", "status": "ACTIVE_AT_EPISODE_START", "roster": "Dina", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-001", "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-012", "EVD-S51E04-014", "EVD-S51E04-027", "EVD-S51E04-028" ], "coverage_limit": "Only identified Episode evidence or formal roster; no missingness-to-weakness inference" }, { "player": "Lewis", "status": "ACTIVE_AT_EPISODE_START", "roster": "Dina", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-002", "EVD-S51E04-003", "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-013", "EVD-S51E04-015" ], "coverage_limit": "Only identified Episode evidence or formal roster; no missingness-to-weakness inference" }, { "player": "Sharonda", "status": "ACTIVE_AT_EPISODE_START", "roster": "Dina", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-006", "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-026", "EVD-S51E04-028", "EVD-S51E04-029" ], "coverage_limit": "Only identified Episode evidence or formal roster; no missingness-to-weakness inference" }, { "player": "Eric", "status": "ACTIVE_AT_EPISODE_START", "roster": "Dina", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-014", "EVD-S51E04-027", "EVD-S51E04-028", "EVD-S51E04-030" ], "coverage_limit": "Only identified Episode evidence or formal roster; no missingness-to-weakness inference" }, { "player": "Linnea", "status": "ACTIVE_AT_EPISODE_START", "roster": "Dina", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-031", "EVD-S51E04-032" ], "coverage_limit": "Only identified Episode evidence or formal roster; no missingness-to-weakness inference" }, { "player": "Cristian", "status": "ACTIVE_AT_EPISODE_START", "roster": "Dina", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-011", "EVD-S51E04-031", "EVD-S51E04-032" ], "coverage_limit": "Only identified Episode evidence or formal roster; no missingness-to-weakness inference" }, { "player": "Jelly", "status": "ACTIVE_AT_EPISODE_START", "roster": "Savu", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-004", "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-020", "EVD-S51E04-026", "EVD-S51E04-034", "EVD-S51E04-037", "EVD-S51E04-038", "EVD-S51E04-041", "EVD-S51E04-042" ], "coverage_limit": "Only identified Episode evidence or formal roster; no missingness-to-weakness inference" }, { "player": "Devin", "status": "ACTIVE_AT_EPISODE_START", "roster": "Savu", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-004", "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-020", "EVD-S51E04-021", "EVD-S51E04-026", "EVD-S51E04-033", "EVD-S51E04-036", "EVD-S51E04-039", "EVD-S51E04-043" ], "coverage_limit": "Only identified Episode evidence or formal roster; no missingness-to-weakness inference" }, { "player": "Jenna", "status": "ACTIVE_AT_EPISODE_START", "roster": "Savu", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-006", "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-019", "EVD-S51E04-020", "EVD-S51E04-033", "EVD-S51E04-034", "EVD-S51E04-035", "EVD-S51E04-037", "EVD-S51E04-040", "EVD-S51E04-044", "EVD-S51E04-045", "EVD-S51E04-046", "EVD-S51E04-047", "EVD-S51E04-048", "EVD-S51E04-049", "EVD-S51E04-050", "EVD-S51E04-051", "EVD-S51E04-052" ], "coverage_limit": "Only identified Episode evidence or formal roster; no missingness-to-weakness inference" }, { "player": "Ori", "status": "ACTIVE_AT_EPISODE_START", "roster": "Savu", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-009", "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-026", "EVD-S51E04-036", "EVD-S51E04-040", "EVD-S51E04-043" ], "coverage_limit": "Only identified Episode evidence or formal roster; no missingness-to-weakness inference" }, { "player": "Alexis", "status": "ACTIVE_AT_EPISODE_START", "roster": "Savu", "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-S51E04-005", "EVD-S51E04-010", "EVD-S51E04-019", "EVD-S51E04-035", "EVD-S51E04-040", "EVD-S51E04-042", "EVD-S51E04-043" ], "coverage_limit": "Only identified Episode evidence or formal roster; no missingness-to-weakness inference" }, { "player": "Aaliyah", "status": "DEPARTED_BEFORE_EPISODE_4", "evidence_ids": [], "accepted_input_reference": "Inherited Episode 3 package and its accepted earlier inputs; no historical reassessment" }, { "player": "Ana", "status": "DEPARTED_BEFORE_EPISODE_4", "evidence_ids": [], "accepted_input_reference": "Inherited Episode 3 package and its accepted earlier inputs; no historical reassessment" }, { "player": "Patt", "status": "DEPARTED_BEFORE_EPISODE_4", "evidence_ids": [], "accepted_input_reference": "Inherited Episode 3 package and its accepted earlier inputs; no historical reassessment" }, { "player": "Rob", "status": "DEPARTED_BEFORE_EPISODE_4", "evidence_ids": [], "accepted_input_reference": "Inherited Episode 3 package and its accepted earlier inputs; no historical reassessment" } ], "formal_outcomes": { "swap": [ 6, 6, 5 ], "first_immunity": "Dina", "second_immunity": "Toka", "tribal": "Savu", "eliminated": "Jenna Doore", "remaining": 16, "directly_captioned_read": { "Jenna": 3, "Alexis": 1, "ballots_read": 4 }, "reported_final_total": { "Jenna": 4, "Alexis": 1, "source_id": "S04", "status": "REPORTED_NOT_FULL_DIRECT_BALLOT_AUDIT" }, "individual_voter_ledger": "NOT_DIRECTLY_VERIFIED", "ordinal_discrepancy": "Host says fifth voted out; there are four vote eliminations plus Rob’s voluntary departure. Name the exit; do not relabel Rob as a vote-out." }, "issues": [ { "id": "G01", "detail": "Unresolved speakers and confessional camera context; use CONTEXT_INDETERMINATE rather than italics as proof.", "dependent_claim": "Specific speaker/context claims only" }, { "id": "G02", "detail": "Three Jenna/one Alexis read is not the full five ballots; final 4–1 is attributed reporting. No full named ballot ledger inspected.", "dependent_claim": "Exact direct tally/voter identity claims" }, { "id": "G03", "detail": "Official recap’s four total refers to shown read, and its fourth eliminated/fifth departure language differs from host fifth voted out.", "dependent_claim": "Distinguish read total, reported final total and exit ordinal" }, { "id": "G04", "detail": "Continuous audiovisual/uncaptioned review absent; no diagnosis of Lewis or private-motive inference.", "dependent_claim": "Visual-only events, health and motive" }, { "id": "G05", "detail": "Original caption first availability not observed; publisher metadata does not establish prospective T+0.", "dependent_claim": "Exact availability-clock assertion" }, { "id": "G06", "detail": "Jenna’s unseen Ori conversation, intended Jelly countertarget and relationship explanations are later self-report.", "dependent_claim": "No hindsight inserted into Episode record" }, { "id": "G07", "detail": "Advantage deployment/expiry unknown where not shown; old transfer terms preserved exactly.", "dependent_claim": "Resource-specific effectiveness and expiry" }, { "id": "G08", "detail": "Earlier availability notes said v104 was absent; October 16 live check found it and its full text was read. Preserve the dated correction.", "dependent_claim": "Do not repeat the superseded absence statement as current" } ], "proposed_audience_question": "Why did Jenna try to rebuild with Devin and Jelly after they had already voted against her?", "power_effects": [], "scores": [], "ranks": [], "conclusions": [], "public_copy": [], "page_changes": [], "audit_independence": "NON_INDEPENDENT_CODEX_SELF_AUDIT", "next_phase_authority": "NOT_AUTHORIZED_BY_THIS_PHASE_1_REQUEST", "publication": "NONE" }