[
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-001",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-SRT-SAVED",
    "paraphrase": "Devin says he and Brady were on opposite sides of the first vote but remained good because they had been honest about their positions.",
    "limit": "Self-report of the relationship at that moment; no season-long durability claim.",
    "context": "IN_GAME_CONFESSIONAL_AND_CAMP_CONVERSATION",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-TIMELY-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-002",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-SRT-SAVED",
    "paraphrase": "Ana explains she wanted multiple names in circulation to create a rift and says she told Carter everything.",
    "limit": "Ana's stated intent does not establish every later recipient effect or exclusive causation.",
    "context": "IN_GAME_CONFESSIONAL",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-TIMELY-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-003",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-SRT-SAVED",
    "paraphrase": "Alexis says she no longer trusts Ana and decides to spread that Ana is naming people; Linnea relays the information to Sharonda.",
    "limit": "Presented chain only; no claim that Alexis solely caused the eventual vote.",
    "context": "IN_GAME_CONFESSIONAL_AND_CAMP_CONVERSATION",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-TIMELY-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-004",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-SRT-SAVED",
    "paraphrase": "Brady injures his thumb while chopping wood and says a quarter is missing.",
    "limit": "No medical diagnosis beyond the recorded episode statements.",
    "context": "IN_GAME_EVENT",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-TIMELY-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-005",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-SRT-SAVED",
    "paraphrase": "Medical staff say they will provide antibiotics and get Brady ready for the challenge; Brady reports he is allowed to remain.",
    "limit": "Formal participation result only; no prognosis beyond the episode record.",
    "context": "MEDICAL_ASSESSMENT_IN_EPISODE",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-TIMELY-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-006",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-SRT-SAVED",
    "paraphrase": "Jeff announces that Lewis joins Toka.",
    "limit": "Formal membership state only.",
    "context": "FORMAL_CHALLENGE_ARENA",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-TIMELY-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-007",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-SRT-SAVED",
    "paraphrase": "Jelly hooks the final bag and Toka wins reward.",
    "limit": "Challenge result only; no Power inference.",
    "context": "FORMAL_REWARD_CHALLENGE",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-TIMELY-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-008",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-SRT-SAVED",
    "paraphrase": "Kristin injures her foot during the reward challenge and later describes swelling and pain while stating she intends to remain.",
    "limit": "Self-report and continued participation only; no medical diagnosis.",
    "context": "IN_GAME_EVENT_AND_CONFESSIONAL",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-TIMELY-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-009",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-SRT-SAVED",
    "paraphrase": "Rob questions the challenge pairing and repeats criticism after Linnea responds.",
    "limit": "Occurrence and responses only; emotion and motive beyond words are not inferred.",
    "context": "IN_GAME_CAMP_CONVERSATION",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-TIMELY-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-010",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-SRT-SAVED",
    "paraphrase": "Jelly leaves camp to search, finds a normal hidden immunity idol, and reads that votes against the holder will not count when played.",
    "limit": "Access and rule state only; no influence or effectiveness inference.",
    "context": "IN_GAME_SEARCH_AND_RULE_READ",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-TIMELY-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-011",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-SRT-SAVED",
    "paraphrase": "The episode establishes that Jelly tells Patt about the idol; Patt says the disclosure was what she needed to cement the relationship.",
    "limit": "Recipient self-report supports the immediate relationship effect only.",
    "context": "IN_GAME_CONFESSIONAL_AND_CAMP_CONVERSATION",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-TIMELY-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-012",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-SRT-SAVED",
    "paraphrase": "Jelly and Patt discuss a possible five-person group with Brady, Devin, and Mike.",
    "limit": "Proposal and expressed enthusiasm only; durability and complete member acceptance are not established.",
    "context": "IN_GAME_CAMP_CONVERSATION_AND_CONFESSIONAL",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-TIMELY-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-013",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-SRT-SAVED",
    "paraphrase": "Multiple Savu comments describe Eric as irritating; a confessional says an immediate vote would be 9-1 Eric.",
    "limit": "In-game estimate before the immunity loss, not a formal ballot count.",
    "context": "IN_GAME_CAMP_AND_CONFESSIONAL",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-TIMELY-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-014",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-SRT-SAVED",
    "paraphrase": "Maggie lands the final ball and Toka wins immunity.",
    "limit": "Formal result only; no Power inference.",
    "context": "FORMAL_IMMUNITY_CHALLENGE",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-TIMELY-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-015",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-SRT-SAVED",
    "paraphrase": "Rob says Eric has been the target for two days. Ana first offers Kristin as the name for Eric, then offers herself as the decoy and immediately regrets it.",
    "limit": "Describes presented plan development only; later outcome has multiple contributors.",
    "context": "IN_GAME_CONFESSIONAL_AND_CAMP_CONVERSATION",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-TIMELY-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-016",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-SRT-SAVED",
    "paraphrase": "Information that Ana named Alexis, Linnea, and Sharonda circulates; Sharonda tells Ori that voting Ana would create a majority and Ori says he will shift from Eric.",
    "limit": "Group contribution is distributed; exact final voter identities are not established in Phase 1.",
    "context": "IN_GAME_CAMP_CONVERSATION_AND_CONFESSIONAL",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-TIMELY-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-017",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-SRT-SAVED",
    "paraphrase": "Rob says he is considering sacrificing himself, tells Eric to follow instructions at Tribal, and says an idol is in his pocket.",
    "limit": "Rob's stated intent is not proof that Eric accepts or that the plan changes the vote.",
    "context": "IN_GAME_CONFESSIONAL_AND_CAMP_CONVERSATION",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-TIMELY-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-018",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-SRT-SAVED",
    "paraphrase": "Eric says he will not blindly follow an undisclosed plan and wants enough facts to make an educated decision.",
    "limit": "Recorded response only; private reasoning beyond the words is not inferred.",
    "context": "IN_GAME_CONFESSIONAL",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-TIMELY-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-019",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-SRT-SAVED",
    "paraphrase": "Rob asks to speak privately with Eric at Tribal. The private words are not captioned; the group then proceeds to vote.",
    "limit": "The private exchange content is unavailable in captions and is not reconstructed here from visuals.",
    "context": "FORMAL_TRIBAL_COUNCIL",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-TIMELY-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-020",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-TVLINE-RECAP",
    "paraphrase": "Two sources report that Rob intended Eric to use his Shot in the Dark, would protect Eric with his idol if needed, and tried to vote for himself; production required a valid revote and Rob wrote Eric.",
    "limit": "Do not treat the private Tribal words or self-vote attempt as directly caption-observed; do not infer Eric's private motive.",
    "context": "TRIBAL_ACTION_RECONSTRUCTION",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-TIMELY-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-021",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-SRT-SAVED",
    "paraphrase": "No idol or advantage is played. The read shows Ana, four Eric votes, then five more Ana votes, and Ana is eliminated on the final read.",
    "limit": "The exact 6-4 split remains a claim-level Source Conflict because the official Paramount+ recap states 5-4. Individual voter identities are not recorded.",
    "context": "FORMAL_TRIBAL_COUNCIL",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-TIMELY-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-022",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-SRT-SAVED",
    "paraphrase": "Closing credit states captioning sponsored by CBS and identifies Media Access Group at WGBH.",
    "limit": "Credit plus alignment supports lineage but does not make SubtitleCat an independent or official publisher.",
    "context": "CAPTION_CREDIT",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-TIMELY-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-023",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-SRT-SAVED",
    "paraphrase": "Ana says she played too hard too quickly, made many early promises, and is disappointed to leave.",
    "limit": "Exit self-assessment only; no proof of other players' motives.",
    "context": "POST_ELIMINATION_EXIT_WORDS",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-TIMELY-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-024",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-TVLINE-ANA",
    "paraphrase": "Ana says Alexis was the person throwing names and then reframed the situation against her.",
    "limit": "Ana's perspective establishes that she made the statement; it does not independently prove Alexis's motive or sole causation.",
    "context": "POST_GAME_INTERVIEW",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-POSTGAME-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-025",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-TVINSIDER-ANA",
    "paraphrase": "Ana describes Carter as her closest ally and recounts the reported Rob plan involving Eric's Shot in the Dark, Rob's idol, and an attempted self-vote.",
    "limit": "Same Ana perspective origin; does not independently prove Rob's internal motive or private instructions.",
    "context": "POST_GAME_INTERVIEW",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-POSTGAME-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-026",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-SHARON-ANA",
    "paraphrase": "A third Ana interview publication is registered and agrees that the vote was 6-4.",
    "limit": "Zero additional independent-perspective weight; used only for consistency.",
    "context": "POST_GAME_INTERVIEW",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-POSTGAME-v01"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-027",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-USMAG-ANA-CARTER",
    "paraphrase": "Ana describes an organic big-sister/little-brother bond, says she tells Carter everything, asks him to stay safe because she needs him, and joins a reciprocal No. 1 and endgame commitment.",
    "limit": "Supports Ana-to-Carter Referent Power only as a bounded dyadic commitment; durability, protection, vote control, and exact chronology are not established.",
    "context": "IN_GAME_INTERVIEW_AND_PLAYER_TO_PLAYER_STRATEGIC_SPEECH",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-EARLY-RETRO-v02"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-028",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-USMAG-ANA-CARTER",
    "paraphrase": "Carter says the relationship is organic, that he and Ana are on the same page, that she is his go-to and trusted partner, and that he wants to play with her at all costs; the pair discuss a reciprocal No. 1 and endgame plan.",
    "limit": "Supports Carter-to-Ana Referent Power only as a bounded dyadic commitment; durability, protection, vote control, and exact chronology are not established.",
    "context": "IN_GAME_INTERVIEW_AND_PLAYER_TO_PLAYER_STRATEGIC_SPEECH",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-EARLY-RETRO-v02"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-029",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-USMAG-ANA-CARTER",
    "paraphrase": "The pair directly identify each other as No. 1 and discuss going to the end together; Ana's safety request and both confessionals tie that commitment to trust and personal bond.",
    "limit": "One shared scene can support two directional effects because each affected player states their own relationship-linked decision; it is not a numeric double score.",
    "context": "PLAYER_TO_PLAYER_STRATEGIC_SPEECH",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-EARLY-RETRO-v02"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-030",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-TVINSIDER-PROBST",
    "paraphrase": "Jeff Probst's Field Notes say production stopped Rob from voting for himself and that Probst could not track the strategic logic.",
    "limit": "Retrospective support for occurrence and rule intervention only; no new Rob-to-Eric Power effect.",
    "context": "FORMAL_HOST_OR_RULE_STATEMENT",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-EARLY-RETRO-v02"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-031",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-TDT-VOTE",
    "paraphrase": "True Dork Times supplies a 6-4 secondary result reconstruction and individual voter map.",
    "limit": "Cannot override the official Paramount+ recap's 5-4 statement or authorize an exact voter map.",
    "context": "EDITORIAL_RECONSTRUCTION",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-EARLY-RETRO-v02"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-032",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-POPHEIST-VOTE",
    "paraphrase": "Pop Heist supplies a 6-4 secondary result reconstruction and individual voter map.",
    "limit": "Cannot override the official Paramount+ recap's 5-4 statement or authorize an exact voter map.",
    "context": "EDITORIAL_RECONSTRUCTION",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-EARLY-RETRO-v02"
  },
  {
    "evidence_id": "EVD-S51E02-033",
    "source_id": "SRC-S51E02-INSIDE-STATS",
    "paraphrase": "Inside Survivor reports a 6-4 vote statistic.",
    "limit": "Cannot override the official Paramount+ recap's 5-4 statement or authorize an exact voter map.",
    "context": "EDITORIAL_RECONSTRUCTION",
    "wave": "EW-S51E02-EARLY-RETRO-v02"
  }
]